Singer, Songwriter, Performer, or Model/Personality?

[Make me your Dream Life]

Or producer! 
 

How the game works: state an artist and the user below comments their opinion on which quadrant the artist fits best (not all, but best) / most natural. 
 

Model/Personality refers to, an artist that is more about their personality/ fame taking more of a front, sometimes more so than the music. I.e. Selena Gomez (personally think sometimes she’s more of a role model/model with great tracks). 

Wanted to include Rapper too, long title but also considered the genre/singing style for artists as both umbrella’d into Singer and/or Songwriter. 
 

Thought about artists, but also that could be considered into the 4 types, as well as them being some kind of artist overall. 

 

Example: Lana Del Rey, songwriter. 

 

First:

Miley Cyrus

[the ocean]

miley cyrus, personality

(she can write excellent songs and she's also a great performer, but i would say that most people know of her for her personality)

 

adele (we all know the answer to this one kii)

[lili]

adele, performer

 

fka twigs

 

[Make me your Dream Life]

Performer 

Beyonce 

[the ocean]

27 minutes ago, lili said:

adele, performer

 

the way this a lie

 

18 minutes ago, Diamantes said:

Beyonce 

 

singer ABSOLUTELY (she can also knock a performance though whew - see: beyonce experience 2007, formation tour & coachella)

 

edit: charles xbox charli xcx

[Make me your Dream Life]

2 minutes ago, avenue said:

 

the way this a lie

 

 

singer ABSOLUTELY (she can also knock a performance though whew - see: beyonce experience 2007, formation tour & coachella)

with Beyonce, it's honestly just a bit trickier cus she's great with a LOT. but I think for her, I think at this point she's a brand.
also, personally think as a whole, a performer. she sings, dances, and idk about acting so much,
but she performs them all so well.

next artist: Ariana Grande 

[lili]

2 minutes ago, avenue said:

 

the way this a lie

 

Maybe it's about me being a non-native speaker, but I just dig her live performances, that's why I said performer. Do y'all mean "performer" in the sense of entertainer?

[the ocean]

Just now, Diamantes said:

with Beyonce, it's honestly just a bit trickier cus she's great with a LOT. but I think for her, I think at this point she's a brand. also, personally think as a whole, a performer. 

 

i think that pre-selftitled she was a singer that could hold great live performances

post-selftitled exactly what you said

 

honestly virgos manage to be great at a lot of things idk how they do it

 

1 minute ago, Diamantes said:

next artist: Ariana Grande 

 

personality

she can sing good but tbh it sounds like she's trying to be mariah and failing because nobody can be mariah

 

next artist: Dua Lipa

[the ocean]

1 minute ago, lili said:

Maybe it's about me being a non-native speaker, but I just dig her live performances, that's why I said performer. Do y'all mean "performer" in the sense of entertainer?

 

yeah

 

ok to essentially to clarify:

 

- singer :: known for their vocal ability (ie. Mariah Carey or Adele)

- songwriter :: known for their lyrics (ie. Taylor Swift or Lana)

- performer :: known for their ability to captivate an audience / do many things (ie. Beyoncé or Madonna)

- personality :: known for their personality (more than their music) (ie. Selena Gomez or Ariana Grande imo)

[lili]

3 minutes ago, avenue said:

 

yeah

 

ok to essentially to clarify:

 

- singer :: known for their vocal ability (ie. Mariah Carey or Adele)

- songwriter :: known for their lyrics (ie. Taylor Swift or Lana)

- performer :: known for their ability to captivate an audience / do many things (ie. Beyoncé or Madonna)

- personality :: known for their personality (more than their music) (ie. Selena Gomez or Ariana Grande imo)

Ah, I get it now. Thanks for explaining! 

sorry for butchering the thread. Next artist was Dua Lipa

[DeadSeaOfMercury]

Hotter than Hell.

Going with personality, She seems amazing.

even though I really love her music.

 

 

Madonna

[Make me your Dream Life]

Performer

 

Charli XCX

[the ocean]

songwriter but not in the way lana & taylor are

 

she can write a catchy af hook in her sleep like she is just a pop factory

 

madame gags

[Mer]

literally who tf is madame gag? idk i barely watch straight p*rn anymore so sorry, performer I guess? 

 

Lady Gaga

[Vanilla Icy]

personality

 

rihanna

[Make me your Dream Life]

personality, but also, boss

Taylor Swift 

[CinnamonGay]

Performer (all the outfit changes and fun themes)

 

Lorde

[BartenderDeco]

songwriter

pheobe bridgers

[the ocean]

6 hours ago, Mer said:

literally who tf is madame gag? idk i barely watch straight p*rn anymore so sorry, performer I guess? 

 

Lady Gaga

 

you figured it out in the post congratulations 

 

also i disagree tbh with some of these answers but i guess it’s what makes it fun

[violentvioletsky]

On 4/18/2022 at 5:39 PM, BartenderDeco said:

songwriter

pheobe bridgers

 

Songwriter

 

Caroline Polachek