Fingertips

No

Some of you really have run off some amazing members with your draining negativity; hope you're feeling proud of yourselves.

Candy Necklace really ended up being the dark horse of this album

4 stars from The Guardian? Didn't they hate her music for many years? Or was that a different magazine?

Kintsugi.......

Didn't you make a claim that you're a musician two seconds ago? I guess you and bartenderrr can keep each other for company in your club of imaginary resumé's. "Unmelodic" isn't being used correctly. Whether dissonant or meandering, the songs still have a melody. Catch up.

If you don't understand what a melody is, maybe you should stop running your mouth? Just a thought Rockefeller, my umbrella...

Yup, but they're VERY close. I think this is my official ranking (sorry, I know you love PT, it's just not my cup of tea personally):

Masterpiece

Yeah, it doesn't sound THAT bad. You can hear all of the lyrics and the melody clearly enough. The HQ will make it really punch.

It's a phone recording of the vinyl, but it still sounds better than any of the "rosemead exclusive baby" messes.

You just said that you blame Jack Antonoff for Lana creating piano ballads. Read what you wrote. Scram.

A producer's function is to convey their artist's wishes. They aren't holding Lana at gunpoint to create "piano ballads" in order to torture you.