The Siren

i didnt know Sticks & Stones was a song title edit - wait, it leaked??? when where huh??

@Anonymcomenter you forgot Intervals in the CB unleaked list. there's also the (two apparently) final versions of Drowning

yes these all are *unleaked Cry Baby era outtakes except for Alone technically, that one started in 2009 KOTA was 2014 idk idc what yall say, Maze makes more sense in MM3 sessions than After School (and Maze is so fucking good wtf)

wait i was just going through my files and JUST realized that Spin the Bottle leaked i havent listened to it yet

i refuse to download the LQ file

i distinctly remember reading a conversation between a few people saying MPH being their least fav from the album

didnt we just do this same thing just prior to the Portals announcement?

im trying to list every Mel song we know by recording date so as many as you can assist on would be appreciated heres what i got so far idk what i forgot to put at Apr 9 2014 tho, i left it blank for some reason edit 2 - i made a google drive with commenting available to anyone with the link for corrections https://docs.google.com/document/d/10HW55KPdDwXMOvVVzfh4qaPCSoUf3wuv8RgbAX8cBn4/edit?usp=sharing recorded june 2 2017, so after k-12 was completed as far as we know

i like keeping every version of each song if i can - not always including instrumental demo versions. sometimes i like playing through them in order to hear whats changed throughout the song's lifetime before its final (or latest leaked) version but i dont keep instrumental or acapella versions tho oh yeah i dont have that in my files so i skipped that one https://melanie-martinez.fandom.com/wiki/Trophy_Wife?so=search edit - if anyone can help resurface (or upload) any most updated masterpost/tracker of pre-portals era outtakes PLEASE

@Coloringbooks do you happen to know any of the recording dates for the MM3 leaks? the wiki only had Mother of Pearl cos they wont include any leaks that are not confirmed scrapped

are you counting the multiple demo versions of songs? in that case itd be closer to like 160 or something. i KNOW im missing a large chunk of those demo versions and i have 132 songs (released and unreleased; including the Portals snippets) oh yeah, the deluxe was original three additional songs but she couldnt stop writing so it eventually became the 7 track EP

i disregarded the baby theme for mine cos thats what turned off a lot of people outside of the fanbase in 2015 they used to to call her a pedo

Copy Cat doesnt have a recording date, does anyone know it? https://melanie-martinez.fandom.com/wiki/Copy_Cat (also we dont have a month/day for any of K-12 songs )

i think this may have been one of my biggest issues with Miley's latest album. the vocals were a little too weak compared to what we've heard from her previously. id say fans worried about Mel smoking weed may be warranted here while on the subject of recording dates, the Wiki was updated for Erase Her to say June 2nd, 2017 is this date true?

ok so if all of the Cry Baby sessions were split into two separate albums, this is what i'd configure (quickly arranged without listening to the songs or reading the lyrics) 2014 album (2013 recordings) - Night Mime Cry Baby Dollhouse Birthing Addicts A Million Men Drowning I Think I'm Crazy Carousel Heart at the Door Psycho Lovers Gold Diggin Love Night Mime Bittersweet Tragedy Time Flies Dear Porcupines - deluxe Intervals - deluxe Curly Cue - deluxe Rough Love 2015 album (2014 recordings) - Arts & Crafts King of the Arcade Bombs on Monday Morning - deluxe 99 Cent Store Pity Party Ring Pop Rocking Horse - deluxe Dead to Me - deluxe Where do Babies Come from? Cake Tag You're It Soap Haunted Arts & Crafts Sippy Cup Half-Hearted Mrs Potato Head Mad Hatter listen to Erase Her and then Lost & Found

tbh the only song i like on the ep is the single Erase Her on loop

tbh Erase Her could have replaced Teacher's Pet

just think; without the K-12 film, Portals would have been her fourth album! would have? most of us currently do hate the EP

perhaps you can correct the dates

idk but id think i would count it in the era sessions in case there ever was a reissue planned around the time? also, Seesaw is the only outtake we have that was recorded in 2015

so i managed to go through (i think) every unreleased song from the Cry Baby era and sorted the whole era by recording date am i missing any?

comments say its not the real title https://melanie-martinez.fandom.com/wiki/Erase_Her After School. K-12 was finished in 2017

wait - Drowning was 2013? https://melanie-martinez.fandom.com/wiki/Drowning

tbh idk what it sounds like ive only played it 16 times total https://www.last.fm/user/Christopher-Roy/library/music/Melanie+Martinez/Arts+&+Crafts i think we all collectively forgot about that

im getting conflicting dates for Cake, April 2014 and July 19 2014 https://melanie-martinez.fandom.com/wiki/Cake