Alloy

You don't wanna let me doooooown
'Cause you don't really feel like drowning

First mention and circa dates for Cry Baby outtakes/sessions (2013-2015):
 
NOTE THESE ARE ALL ONLY AFTER SEPTEMBER 19th, 2013 AND GO INTO AUGUST 1st, 2015
 
99¢ Store - CIRCA (May 15th, 2014) likely recorded before May 15th, first demo was remastered on May 15th, 2014.
Alphabet Boy - CIRCA (April 4th, 2014)
Animal Crackers - CIRCA (2013-2015)
Arts & Crafts - CIRCA (August 1st, 2014)
Band Aid - CIRCA (2014) possibly in August 2014 with Mad Hatter sessions.
Bombs on Monday Morning - CIRCA (March 3rd, 2014)
Bubble Boy - CIRCA (2013) was rumoured to be recorded in 2013.
Cake - CIRCA (November 12th, 2014) likely from July 2014.
Carousel - CIRCA (October 24th, 2013) final mix remastered April 8th, 2014.
Coloring Book - CIRCA (May 17th, 2014)
Cooties - CIRCA (2014) possibly in May 2014 with Teddy Bear sessions.
Cry Baby - CIRCA (October 24th, 2013)
Dead To Me - CIRCA (January 21st, 2014) final mix remastered April 8th, 2014.
Dollhouse - CIRCA (September 19th, 2013) final mix remastered April 8th, 2014.
Drowning - CIRCA (2013) it’s been mentioned before to have been from 2013.
Gingerbread Man - CIRCA (August 1st, 2015) technically not a Cry Baby outtake, but was during sessions.
Gold Diggin Love - CIRCA (January 17th, 2014) possibly recorded in 2013.
Half Hearted - CIRCA (December 11th, 2014)
Haunted - CIRCA (2014)
I Scream - CIRCA (May 28th, 2015) possibly written in 2014.
Jumprope - CIRCA (August 5th, 2014)
Mad Hatter - CIRCA (August 19th, 2014)
Melatonin - CIRCA (2014) possibly not even a song but was mentioned by PlasmaLizard.
Memories - CIRCA (2013) was rumored to be recorded around Dollhouse in 2013.
Milk and Cookies - CIRCA (May 28th, 2014)
Mrs. Potato Head - CIRCA (February 16th, 2015) was written/conceptualized sometime in July/August 2014 when Mel was in LA.
Pacify Her - CIRCA (April 25th, 2014) third demo remastered on May 15th, 2014.
Patient - CIRCA (July 31st, 2014)
Pity Party - CIRCA (April 2014)
Play Date - CIRCA (December 17th, 2014)
Psycho Lovers - CIRCA (December 23rd, 2013)
Ring Pop - CIRCA (April 2014) possibly recorded in March 2014 but was before ZZZZ’s recording date, third demo remastered on May 15th, 2014.
Rocking Horse - CIRCA (November 21st, 2014)
Rotten Milk - CIRCA (2014) was likely recorded around Bombs on Monday Morning’s recording date (March 2014) as it was recorded in North Carolina and that is where Cubby is located.
Run - CIRCA (November 3rd, 2013) studio version was uploaded on April 4th, 2014 on Melanie’s manager’s soundcloud.
Schizo - CIRCA (October 24th, 2013)
See Saw - CIRCA (June 2015)
Shadow Puppets - CIRCA (2014)
Sippy Cup - CIRCA (August 29th, 2014)
Soap - CIRCA (July 22nd, 2014)
Tag, You're It - CIRCA (September 10th, 2014) was remastered on October 13th, 2014.
Teddy Bear - CIRCA (May 6th, 2014) first demo was remastered for the second time on May 15th, 2014.
Training Wheels - CIRCA (November 26th, 2014)
Trophy Wife - CIRCA (March 25th, 2015)
Twins - CIRCA (October 29th, 2014)
Unhappy Meal - CIRCA (2014) allegedly from November 24th, 2014 according to Alex, a former Cuca member.
Where Do Babies Come From - CIRCA (July 6th, 2014) demo was remastered for the second time on August 26th, 2014.
You Love I - CIRCA (January 21st, 2014)
ZZZZ - CIRCA (April 7th, 2014) studio version wasn’t recorded until April 17th, 2014.
 
I put circa for all of these because they could have easily been thought of months before taken into the studio, so confirmed dates will be unknown.
I also tried my best to link to all of the sources.

They said in their list post 
 

Anyone have a better sounding cry baby demo 2?? Mine sounds like it was recorded ten feet away from laptop speaker

First mention and circa dates for MM3 outtakes/sessions (2020-2021).

First mention and circa dates for Cry Baby outtakes/sessions (2013-2015):
 
NOTE THESE ARE ALL ONLY AFTER SEPTEMBER 19th, 2013 AND GO INTO AUGUST 1st, 2015
 
99¢ Store - CIRCA (May 15th, 2014) likely recorded before May 15th, first demo was remastered on May 15th, 2014.
Alphabet Boy - CIRCA (April 4th, 2014)
Animal Crackers - CIRCA (2013-2015)
Arts & Crafts - CIRCA (August 1st, 2014)
Band Aid - CIRCA (2014) possibly in August 2014 with Mad Hatter sessions.
Bombs on Monday Morning - CIRCA (March 3rd, 2014)
Bubble Boy - CIRCA (2013) was rumoured to be recorded in 2013.
Cake - CIRCA (November 12th, 2014) likely from July 2014.
Carousel - CIRCA (October 24th, 2013) final mix remastered April 8th, 2014.
Coloring Book - CIRCA (May 17th, 2014)
Cooties - CIRCA (2014) possibly in May 2014 with Teddy Bear sessions.
Cry Baby - CIRCA (October 24th, 2013)
Dead To Me - CIRCA (January 21st, 2014) final mix remastered April 8th, 2014.
Dollhouse - CIRCA (September 19th, 2013) final mix remastered April 8th, 2014.
Drowning - CIRCA (2013) it’s been mentioned before to have been from 2013.
Gingerbread Man - CIRCA (August 1st, 2015) technically not a Cry Baby outtake, but was during sessions.
Gold Diggin Love - CIRCA (January 17th, 2014) possibly recorded in 2013.
Half Hearted - CIRCA (December 11th, 2014)
Haunted - CIRCA (2014)
I Scream - CIRCA (May 28th, 2015) possibly written in 2014.
Jumprope - CIRCA (August 5th, 2014)
Mad Hatter - CIRCA (August 19th, 2014)
Melatonin - CIRCA (2014) possibly not even a song but was mentioned by PlasmaLizard.
Memories - CIRCA (2013) was rumored to be recorded around Dollhouse in 2013.
Milk and Cookies - CIRCA (May 28th, 2014)
Mrs. Potato Head - CIRCA (February 16th, 2015) was written/conceptualized sometime in July/August 2014 when Mel was in LA.
Pacify Her - CIRCA (April 25th, 2014) third demo remastered on May 15th, 2014.
Patient - CIRCA (July 31st, 2014)
Pity Party - CIRCA (April 2014)
Play Date - CIRCA (December 17th, 2014)
Psycho Lovers - CIRCA (December 23rd, 2013)
Ring Pop - CIRCA (April 2014) possibly recorded in March 2014 but was before ZZZZ’s recording date, third demo remastered on May 15th, 2014.
Rocking Horse - CIRCA (November 21st, 2014)
Rotten Milk - CIRCA (2014) was likely recorded around Bombs on Monday Morning’s recording date (March 2014) as it was recorded in North Carolina and that is where Cubby is located.
Run - CIRCA (November 3rd, 2013) studio version was uploaded on April 4th, 2014 on Melanie’s manager’s soundcloud.
Schizo - CIRCA (October 24th, 2013)
See Saw - CIRCA (June 2015)
Shadow Puppets - CIRCA (2014)
Sippy Cup - CIRCA (August 29th, 2014)
Soap - CIRCA (July 22nd, 2014)
Tag, You're It - CIRCA (September 10th, 2014) was remastered on October 13th, 2014.
Teddy Bear - CIRCA (May 6th, 2014) first demo was remastered for the second time on May 15th, 2014.
Training Wheels - CIRCA (November 26th, 2014)
Trophy Wife - CIRCA (March 25th, 2015)
Twins - CIRCA (October 29th, 2014)
Unhappy Meal - CIRCA (2014) allegedly from November 24th, 2014 according to Alex, a former Cuca member.
Where Do Babies Come From - CIRCA (July 6th, 2014) demo was remastered for the second time on August 26th, 2014.
You Love I - CIRCA (January 21st, 2014)
ZZZZ - CIRCA (April 7th, 2014) studio version wasn’t recorded until April 17th, 2014.
 
I put circa for all of these because they could have easily been thought of months before taken into the studio, so confirmed dates will be unknown.
I also tried my best to link to all of the sources.

I discluded Bittersweet Tragedy because it was in June and Night Mime was July 2013 which was before September 2013. But yeah it took a while to pit together so I'm glad you enjoy.

First mention and circa dates for MM3 outtakes/sessions (2020-2021).

I discluded Bittersweet Tragedy because it was in June and Night Mime was July 2013 which was before September 2013. But yeah it took a while to pit together so I'm glad you enjoy.

First mention and circa dates for MM3 outtakes/sessions (2020-2021).

First mention and circa dates for Cry Baby outtakes/sessions (2013-2015):
 
NOTE THESE ARE ALL ONLY AFTER SEPTEMBER 19th, 2013 AND GO INTO AUGUST 1st, 2015
 
99¢ Store - CIRCA (May 15th, 2014) likely recorded before May 15th, first demo was remastered on May 15th, 2014.
Alphabet Boy - CIRCA (April 4th, 2014)
Animal Crackers - CIRCA (2013-2015)
Arts & Crafts - CIRCA (August 1st, 2014)
Band Aid - CIRCA (2014) possibly in August 2014 with Mad Hatter sessions.
Bombs on Monday Morning - CIRCA (March 3rd, 2014)
Bubble Boy - CIRCA (2013) was rumoured to be recorded in 2013.
Cake - CIRCA (November 12th, 2014) likely from July 2014.
Carousel - CIRCA (October 24th, 2013) final mix remastered April 8th, 2014.
Coloring Book - CIRCA (May 17th, 2014)
Cooties - CIRCA (2014) possibly in May 2014 with Teddy Bear sessions.
Cry Baby - CIRCA (October 24th, 2013)
Dead To Me - CIRCA (January 21st, 2014) final mix remastered April 8th, 2014.
Dollhouse - CIRCA (September 19th, 2013) final mix remastered April 8th, 2014.
Drowning - CIRCA (2013) it’s been mentioned before to have been from 2013.
Gingerbread Man - CIRCA (August 1st, 2015) technically not a Cry Baby outtake, but was during sessions.
Gold Diggin Love - CIRCA (January 17th, 2014) possibly recorded in 2013.
Half Hearted - CIRCA (December 11th, 2014)
Haunted - CIRCA (2014)
I Scream - CIRCA (May 28th, 2015) possibly written in 2014.
Jumprope - CIRCA (August 5th, 2014)
Mad Hatter - CIRCA (August 19th, 2014)
Melatonin - CIRCA (2014) possibly not even a song but was mentioned by PlasmaLizard.
Memories - CIRCA (2013) was rumored to be recorded around Dollhouse in 2013.
Milk and Cookies - CIRCA (May 28th, 2014)
Mrs. Potato Head - CIRCA (February 16th, 2015) was written/conceptualized sometime in July/August 2014 when Mel was in LA.
Pacify Her - CIRCA (April 25th, 2014) third demo remastered on May 15th, 2014.
Patient - CIRCA (July 31st, 2014)
Pity Party - CIRCA (April 2014)
Play Date - CIRCA (December 17th, 2014)
Psycho Lovers - CIRCA (December 23rd, 2013)
Ring Pop - CIRCA (April 2014) possibly recorded in March 2014 but was before ZZZZ’s recording date, third demo remastered on May 15th, 2014.
Rocking Horse - CIRCA (November 21st, 2014)
Rotten Milk - CIRCA (2014) was likely recorded around Bombs on Monday Morning’s recording date (March 2014) as it was recorded in North Carolina and that is where Cubby is located.
Run - CIRCA (November 3rd, 2013) studio version was uploaded on April 4th, 2014 on Melanie’s manager’s soundcloud.
Schizo - CIRCA (October 24th, 2013)
See Saw - CIRCA (June 2015)
Shadow Puppets - CIRCA (2014)
Sippy Cup - CIRCA (August 29th, 2014)
Soap - CIRCA (July 22nd, 2014)
Tag, You're It - CIRCA (September 10th, 2014) was remastered on October 13th, 2014.
Teddy Bear - CIRCA (May 6th, 2014) first demo was remastered for the second time on May 15th, 2014.
Training Wheels - CIRCA (November 26th, 2014)
Trophy Wife - CIRCA (March 25th, 2015)
Twins - CIRCA (October 29th, 2014)
Unhappy Meal - CIRCA (2014) allegedly from November 24th, 2014 according to Alex, a former Cuca member.
Where Do Babies Come From - CIRCA (July 6th, 2014) demo was remastered for the second time on August 26th, 2014.
You Love I - CIRCA (January 21st, 2014)
ZZZZ - CIRCA (April 7th, 2014) studio version wasn’t recorded until April 17th, 2014.
 
I put circa for all of these because they could have easily been thought of months before taken into the studio, so confirmed dates will be unknown.
I also tried my best to link to all of the sources.

First mention and circa dates for Cry Baby outtakes/sessions (2013-2015):
 
NOTE THESE ARE ALL ONLY AFTER SEPTEMBER 19th, 2013 AND GO INTO AUGUST 1st, 2015
 
99¢ Store - CIRCA (May 15th, 2014) likely recorded before May 15th, first demo was remastered on May 15th, 2014.
Alphabet Boy - CIRCA (April 4th, 2014)
Animal Crackers - CIRCA (2013-2015)
Arts & Crafts - CIRCA (August 1st, 2014)
Band Aid - CIRCA (2014) possibly in August 2014 with Mad Hatter sessions.
Bombs on Monday Morning - CIRCA (March 3rd, 2014)
Bubble Boy - CIRCA (2013) was rumoured to be recorded in 2013.
Cake - CIRCA (November 12th, 2014) likely from July 2014.
Carousel - CIRCA (October 24th, 2013) final mix remastered April 8th, 2014.
Coloring Book - CIRCA (May 17th, 2014)
Cooties - CIRCA (2014) possibly in May 2014 with Teddy Bear sessions.
Cry Baby - CIRCA (October 24th, 2013)
Dead To Me - CIRCA (January 21st, 2014) final mix remastered April 8th, 2014.
Dollhouse - CIRCA (September 19th, 2013) final mix remastered April 8th, 2014.
Drowning - CIRCA (2013) it’s been mentioned before to have been from 2013.
Gingerbread Man - CIRCA (August 1st, 2015) technically not a Cry Baby outtake, but was during sessions.
Gold Diggin Love - CIRCA (January 17th, 2014) possibly recorded in 2013.
Half Hearted - CIRCA (December 11th, 2014)
Haunted - CIRCA (2014)
I Scream - CIRCA (May 28th, 2015) possibly written in 2014.
Jumprope - CIRCA (August 5th, 2014)
Mad Hatter - CIRCA (August 19th, 2014)
Melatonin - CIRCA (2014) possibly not even a song but was mentioned by PlasmaLizard.
Memories - CIRCA (2013) was rumored to be recorded around Dollhouse in 2013.
Milk and Cookies - CIRCA (May 28th, 2014)
Mrs. Potato Head - CIRCA (February 16th, 2015) was written/conceptualized sometime in July/August 2014 when Mel was in LA.
Pacify Her - CIRCA (April 25th, 2014) third demo remastered on May 15th, 2014.
Patient - CIRCA (July 31st, 2014)
Pity Party - CIRCA (April 2014)
Play Date - CIRCA (December 17th, 2014)
Psycho Lovers - CIRCA (December 23rd, 2013)
Ring Pop - CIRCA (April 2014) possibly recorded in March 2014 but was before ZZZZ’s recording date, third demo remastered on May 15th, 2014.
Rocking Horse - CIRCA (November 21st, 2014)
Rotten Milk - CIRCA (2014) was likely recorded around Bombs on Monday Morning’s recording date (March 2014) as it was recorded in North Carolina and that is where Cubby is located.
Run - CIRCA (November 3rd, 2013) studio version was uploaded on April 4th, 2014 on Melanie’s manager’s soundcloud.
Schizo - CIRCA (October 24th, 2013)
See Saw - CIRCA (June 2015)
Shadow Puppets - CIRCA (2014)
Sippy Cup - CIRCA (August 29th, 2014)
Soap - CIRCA (July 22nd, 2014)
Tag, You're It - CIRCA (September 10th, 2014) was remastered on October 13th, 2014.
Teddy Bear - CIRCA (May 6th, 2014) first demo was remastered for the second time on May 15th, 2014.
Training Wheels - CIRCA (November 26th, 2014)
Trophy Wife - CIRCA (March 25th, 2015)
Twins - CIRCA (October 29th, 2014)
Unhappy Meal - CIRCA (2014) allegedly from November 24th, 2014 according to Alex, a former Cuca member.
Where Do Babies Come From - CIRCA (July 6th, 2014) demo was remastered for the second time on August 26th, 2014.
You Love I - CIRCA (January 21st, 2014)
ZZZZ - CIRCA (April 7th, 2014) studio version wasn’t recorded until April 17th, 2014.
 
I put circa for all of these because they could have easily been thought of months before taken into the studio, so confirmed dates will be unknown.
I also tried my best to link to all of the sources.

I discluded Bittersweet Tragedy because it was in June and Night Mime was July 2013 which was before September 2013. But yeah it took a while to pit together so I'm glad you enjoy.

omg thank u what a great list! 
i think only haunted is july 15, and cake was recorded in the same session w/Pity Party(since wiki says) 
and u forgot Bittersweet Tragedy, Strawberry Fields Forever, Dressed in Mistakes and Night Mime 

is there a finished product with more lyrics? this one sounds lovely x

so here is a list of all the titles confirmed by reliable sources all this is unleaked
 
 
Ak-47
Bubble Boy
Croquet
Shadow Puppets
Memories 
Race
Run
Intervals
Cooties (Demo 2)
Birthing Addicts (Demo 2)
Papercut V5
Night Mime V4
Valerie 
Zippers   * possible alt title for gluestick*
Sophomore 
Headphones
Bike Ride
Lost & Found

Soap, Dollhouse, Carousel, Mrs. Potato Head and Pacify Her remain my favourites!
As for the outtakes, maybe Coloring Book, Schizo, 99c Store, Haunted, Night Mime, Mistakes, Trophy Wife, Zzzz, Jumprope... uh, there's so many so good! 

I don't know a dumber place than Melanie Martinez Wikia community posts section. New brainless posts literally every day

Half Hearted is December 2014.

I wouldn't go that far but yes it's still flawless 
Six years old not seven ?

Half Hearted is December 2014.

Mrs. Potato Head is like 2014, Zzzz voice memo is early 2014, Half Hearted voice memo is late 2014, Psycho Lovers is 2013 and I think I Scream was written in 2014 as it was seemingly teased by Melanie that year

Also for the 2015 songs
 
Mrs. Potato Head - demo 2 Mrs. Potato Head - demo 3 Trophy Wife I Scream Seesaw Psycho Lovers Zzzz - voice memo Half Hearted - worktape

happy birthday cry baby!! the best album ever released 

Happy 6th Birthday Cry Baby, to an album that has raised almost everyone here. Every song on the album is built in such a strong way and is very personal. Mrs. Potato Head is still one of the best pop songs of the generation and I wish Melanie well on her next few albums! We love you Melanie.