NFR Metacritic/Review Thread

[enchaunted 106]

lol just ignore them, it doesn't matter. just don't do the same thing to taylor swift, it's not her fault

 

or i'll go ክፉ ቃል የሚናገሩ እጅግ ይሰቃያሉ ፡፡  በቅርቡ ይጠፋሉ የሚለውን እውነታ መቀበል ብልህነት ነው ፡፡  በፍርድ ላይ ዐረፍተ ነገር አፍርተሃል ፡፡  ንስሐ መግባት ይፈልጋሉ ግን በጣም ዘግይቷል። 

[Hannus 1,618]

Some of these critics deserve to be put down wtf. I haaate reviewers and articles that cannot let go of the 2011 ideas about her. Time's moved on old men.

exactly. as a critic it's their job to be unbiased and focus on the music. 

[ilovetati 15,299]

People should really email Metacritic about the Telegraph review...they've taken off misogynist reviews before.

 

The real bias is the Alexis Guardian review, though. If someone sent the screen shots of Lana mentioning him and the infamous 2014 interview, they would take it off for bias. 

 

They removed LFL's highest score for "bias" but never explained why.

[cooling85 11]

Stupid question: someone said in this topic that Meaghan Garvey will review the album for Pitchfork. Are there some proofs? Or just your speculations?

[Marius 12,804]

Stupid question: someone said in this topic that Meaghan Garvey will review the album for Pitchfork. Are there some proofs? Or just your speculations?

 

I asked her about NFR review and she responded „You know I got you”.

[cooling85 11]

I asked her about NFR review and she responded „You know I got you”.

Yeah, but she already wrote this (great) piece for Billboard: https://www.billboard.com/articles/columns/pop/8527901/lana-del-rey-billboard-cover-story-2019

 

Hope you're right, 'cause if it's her the score will be very high this time.

[theeternalstars 4,576]

Yeah, but she already wrote this (great) piece for Billboard: https://www.billboard.com/articles/columns/pop/8527901/lana-del-rey-billboard-cover-story-2019

 

Hope you're right, 'cause if it's her the score will be very high this time.

 

 

The score is decided by the editorial team as a whole, so it's still up in the air a bit! Sometimes they publish reviews where the writing and the score barely match 

[cooling85 11]

The score is decided by the editorial team as a whole, so it's still up in the air a bit! Sometimes they publish reviews where the writing and the score barely match 

I know that, but i've read many enthusiastic opinions by p4k's team on Twitter. Hope still a dangerous thing, btw.

[Cacciatore 19,347]

About the Guardian review: I'm sending an e-mail claiming the review was highly mysoginist and the guy's judgment was clouded by his own bias regarding Lana's history with the publication, and I encourage y'all to do the same. The email is editorial@metacritic.com

[ilovetati 15,299]

About the Guardian review: I'm sending an e-mail claiming the review was highly mysoginist and the guy's judgment was clouded by his own bias regarding Lana's history with the publication, and I encourage y'all to do the same. The email is editorial@metacritic.com

 

Don't forget to send the screenshot. 

 

[theeternalstars 4,576]

Hate to break it to y'all but the 2014 interview was conducted by Tim Jonze (also of the Guardian).

[ilovetati 15,299]

Hate to break it to y'all but the 2014 interview was conducted by Tim Jonze (also of the Guardian).

 

We know, but there was a back and forth with Alexis on twitter and a lot of problematic tweets on his part.

[Lanas honey pot 1,370]

About the Guardian review: I'm sending an e-mail claiming the review was highly mysoginist and the guy's judgment was clouded by his own bias regarding Lana's history with the publication, and I encourage y'all to do the same. The email is editorial@metacritic.com

paste it so i could send it

[ilovetati 15,299]

paste it so i could send it

Don’t copy and paste the same message - they’ll ignore it

[Cacciatore 19,347]

Don’t copy and paste the same message - they’ll ignore it

 

Yes, they will see it as spam. But essentially I wrote that his review was clouded by his own bias regarding Lana because of that interview and that his views about women in general tend to be very mysoginistic and usually his reviews carry a mysoginistic tone (even cited Taylor, Lizzo and Bey as examples).

[lets ride 799]

def no c&p, if anything it will help our case if we just send a few sentences where we look like normal vaguely offended people and not stans who've dissected and critiqued every line

 

don't use your stan email address + make sure your real one can't be linked back to twitter, instagram, facebook, or lanaboards  if they see one mention of cinnamon girl…... the whole operation is foiled

[Cacciatore 19,347]

send a few sentences where we look like normal vaguely offended people and not stans who've dissected and critiqued every line

 

The problem is: english it's not my first language + i have adhd so I always have the need to make myself come across as clear as I can, which resulted in a three paragraphs e-mail about how mysoginist and disrespectful the guy was  

[drowning mermaid 1,706]

this alexis guy is a fucking asshole though. he tends to score garbage male singers higher than any woman AND he gave high as hope a 3/5! the AUDACITY

[viagra 1,642]

this alexis guy is a fucking asshole though. he tends to score garbage male singers higher than any woman AND he gave high as hope a 3/5! the AUDACITY

 

He and his fragile male ego must have felt threatened listening to NFR (song).

[house of balloons 12,793]

He and his fragile male ego must have felt threatened listening to NFR (song).

he felt personally attacked by 'goddamn manchild', i'm assuming he stopped listening right after that line