Random Lana Discussion Thread

[baddisease 18,121]

6 minutes ago, Dark Angel said:

 

i just don't really understand how you've made numerous posts discussing how lana's done terrible things (most of which really ARE NOT compared to what many other celebrities have done, like let's be for real) but haven't made any effort to do the same for someone who's accused of rape, no, it doesn't necessarily absolve lana of her questionable actions, but i find it hypocritical for you to be criticizing lana for ultimately minor things in the grand scheme of things when somebody you're (mostly) silent about regarding questionable actions has been accused of rape, one of the most evil things you could do to someone

If this was MelanieBoards and in a Random Melanie Discussion Thread, I would be doing that. Also bringing it up on her subreddit got me and others banned for it, so I've done it before there.

 

Regardless, it doesn't change how I feel about Lana and does not, in any way, make it okay what she's done. You're redirecting to Melanie to deflect. And to me, all of those things that both of them have done are terrible and whether or not you think so has no impact on how I feel. And if I wasn't a Melanie fan, you'd find some other reason to try and redirect things away from Lana 

[Demonmic03 11,843]

9 minutes ago, Dark Angel said:

 

i just don't really understand how you've made numerous posts discussing how lana's done terrible things (most of which really ARE NOT compared to what many other celebrities have done, like let's be for real) but haven't made any effort to do the same for someone who's accused of rape, no, it doesn't necessarily absolve lana of her questionable actions, but i find it hypocritical for you to be criticizing lana for ultimately minor things in the grand scheme of things when somebody you're (mostly) silent about regarding questionable actions has been accused of rape, one of the most evil things you could do to someone

sorry to interject but... dark angel got you there

[baddisease 18,121]

Just now, Demonmic03 said:

sorry to interject but... dark angel got you there

 

No they didn't. They decided it would be a cool idea to completely redirect. People who were already prone to glaze Lana would have found another reason or another way to deflect. 

Also Domestic Violence is right up there with rape and people are out here running interference to defend Lana and absolve her of what small amount of responsibility she has in the reaction to that.

[Dark Angel 204,909]

Just now, baddisease said:

 

No they didn't. They decided it would be a cool idea to completely redirect. People who were already prone to glaze Lana would have found another reason or another way to deflect. 

 

i'm sorry, but when you label yourself on your profile as the largest fan of an artist who has been accused of rape while hammering in on lana's supposedly fucked up actions, you really can't act surprised when people bring it up

[Mer 63,729]

I’m confused what anyone expects Lana, TaP, or anyone that’s not in charge of this guy’s work contract to do? 
 

Plus, you can’t just fire someone bc of online claims, that’s grounds for wrongful termination—I hope she’s at least filed a police report.

 

And if she has filed a police report, then really, it can’t be discussed publicly—he’ll be investigated pending the police, and put on leave until a decision is made. From what I understand (albeit not an expert). 

[jaesana 4,076]

12 minutes ago, fl0r1dakil0s said:

 

interpreting these lyrics as coming from a woman who is "morally" okay with domestic abuse seems almost intentionally obtuse and mirrors the backwards mental attitudes of the people who perpetuated the absurd criticism lana received in 2014 for songs like ultraviolence.. media literacy is in the garbage omfg

I enjoy Lana’s flirting with dark themes in her music. UV is my favorite album of hers for this reason. I do not think she condones domestic violence, nor glorifies it.

 

My own personal belief is that she tends to surround herself with strange people - i.e. Jack’s bizarre instagram posts, this bodyguard who is being accused of pretty heinous behavior, and her husband - I’ll be respectful and give him the benefit of the doubt because they’re married, and he seems like he has a kind heart - but he outwardly posted violent things on his Facebook.

 

You misinterpreted my (admittedly badly-worded) indictment of the Smarty lyric as a sign that she’s okay with domestic abuse. I am moreso speaking to her tendency to align herself with morally dubious men, and her reluctance to distance herself from them. 

[baddisease 18,121]

Just now, Dark Angel said:

 

i'm sorry, but when you label yourself on your profile as the largest fan of an artist who has been accused of rape. while hammering in on lana's supposedly fucked up actions, you really can't act surprised when people bring it up

 

You and the others are only doing it to defend Lana, though. I can hammer on both but it makes precisely zero sense to do that on a post not about her.

 

Whataboutism is a fallacy for a reason.

[Mer 63,729]

1 minute ago, jaesana said:

You misinterpreted my (admittedly badly-worded) indictment of the Smarty lyric as a sign that she’s okay with domestic abuse. I am moreso speaking to her tendency to align herself with morally dubious men, and her reluctance to distance herself from them. 

I wouldn’t say she’s “okay” with it, but rather morbidly curious or fascinated by these darker themes—especially in the abstract, artistic form. 
 

I think we all probably surround ourselves with more morally dubious people than we realize, but since we’re not celebrities, no one is digging into our friends/colleagues/etc.‘s closets. 

[Candy Necklace 8,648]

Melanie Martinez was directly accused of rape while Lana contracted with a company that employed someone accused of DV. Both messed up, but one is clearly more responsible for accusations.

[jaesana 4,076]

2 minutes ago, Mer said:

I wouldn’t say she’s “okay” with it, but rather morbidly curious or fascinated by these darker themes—especially in the abstract, artistic form. 
 

I think we all probably surround ourselves with more morally dubious people than we realize, but since we’re not celebrities, no one is digging into our friends/colleagues/etc.‘s closets. 

Mer this was a perfectly succinct way of what I was trying to express. Thank you.

[baddisease 18,121]

Just now, Candy Necklace said:

Melanie Martinez was directly accused of rape while Lana contracted with a company that employed someone accused of DV. Both messed up, but one is clearly more responsible for accusations.

 

Obviously. But I'm not defending her. I'm doing the exact opposite. Y'all are outright defending Lana and like I said, if it wasn't Melanie, it would be something else y'all bring up to run PR for Lana.

[Karolll 138]

[Brooklyn Fetus 4,062]

omg what is going on-

[Karolll 138]

Idk how are any of these things related to Lana, topics being hot for no reason is something that happens all the time but this is just the ridiculous.

On the first place this isnt even a "Random Lana Conversation Thread" anymore,  yall are talking about bad things that other people have done and for what? What do you gain with this..?

The only thing happening is all of you getting this thread closed

Edited 6 hours ago by Karolll
Forgot a word lmao

[jaesana 4,076]

2 minutes ago, Karolll said:

Idk how are any of these things related to Lana, topics being hot for no reason is something that happens all the time but this is just the ridiculous.

On the first place this isnt even a "Random Lana Conversation Thread" anymore,  yall are talking about bad things that other people have done and for what? What do you gain with this..?

The only thing happening is all of you getting this thread closed

I’ll change the subject

remember when Lana attempted whatever this is 

[Karolll 138]

1 minute ago, jaesana said:

I’ll change the subject

remember when Lana attempted whatever this is 

This sent me 

[somber 820]

1 minute ago, jaesana said:

I’ll change the subject

remember when Lana attempted whatever this is 

The fact that I can draw better than Lana  (i can't draw)

[Candy Necklace 8,648]

9 minutes ago, baddisease said:

 

Obviously. But I'm not defending her. I'm doing the exact opposite. Y'all are outright defending Lana and like I said, if it wasn't Melanie, it would be something else y'all bring up to run PR for Lana.

 

12 minutes ago, Candy Necklace said:

Both messed up, but one is clearly more responsible for accusations.

 

[Daytona Beach Sparkler 5,714]

Y'all are so messy 

[baddisease 18,121]

4 minutes ago, Candy Necklace said:

 

 

 

Fine. I'll correct myself: that applies to others and not you