NFR Metacritic/Review Thread

[Cacciatore 19,347]

New reviews, both should count on Metacritic

 

- The Line of Best Fit (7.5/10):

https://www.thelineofbestfit.com/reviews/albums/norman-fcking-rockwell-lana-del-rey-album-review

 

 

Based on this review they should've gave her a 8, it's such a positive review idgi 

[ilovetati 15,299]

The Variety writer liked tweets saying the review was an 80, so be prepared to pull out the receipts when Metacritic misinterprets the review

[SuperMegaStan 9,985]

i'm happy if this stays above 81..... anything above 85 is an absolute YAAAAAS  

[ilovetati 15,299]

http://twitter.com/jemaswad/status/1168554340749062152

 

Yas (Variety writer)

[Cacciatore 19,347]

http://twitter.com/jemaswad/status/1168554340749062152

 

Yas (Variety writer)

 

omg I hope the score rises to 88 after all these new reviews are added 

[theeternalstars 4,576]

I might email metacritic to ask them to not count it since it’s so poorly written

http://twitter.com/jemaswad/status/1168554340749062152

 

Yas (Variety writer)

I never said Jem Aswad was a cunt.

Jem Aswad is my friend.

[ilovetati 15,299]

Now we just need Pitchfork to pull through 

 

I'm still bracing for disappointment. 

 

[theeternalstars 4,576]

Now we just need Pitchfork to pull through

 

I'm still bracing for disappointment.

 

I deadass had a nightmare (literally a nightmare) I woke up to find Pitchfork giving her 6.7 why am I so invested

[domandapiano 12,099]

They gave high as hope a 5.8 and I loved that album so if it’s anywhere higher than that I shall try and remain un-pressed. Pulling for at least an 8 tho

[Off To The Races 2010 demo pls 19,336]

Can't wait for Fantano to give it a 5.

[Psychedelic Pussy 30,108]

melon liked a tweet asking about the lana review, hopefully he’s dropping it today.... I want him to give our girl an 8 or higher pls pls pls

[UltraHeroin 8,803]

I don't even remember what reviews still need to be added. This thread has been such an unexpected little drama lmao

[viagra 1,642]

There is no way Metacritics will take down the Guardian review. Alexis Petridis is one of the most known reviewer in music scene and everybody got used to his stupid reviews of pop albums.

[ilovetati 15,299]

There is no way Metacritics will take down the Guardian review. Alexis Petridis is one of the most known reviewer in music scene and everybody got used to his stupid reviews of pop albums.

 

I'm more interested in them changing the LA Times score to better match the article.

[viagra 1,642]

I'm more interested in them changing the LA Times score to better match the article.

 

I find it unfair that they decide the score themselves if its not given to them. They should demand a score from any magazine. Now the only way they will change it is if the writer would say they had different score in their mind.

[theeternalstars 4,576]

Email the LAtimes reviewer to let them know that their review may have been misconstrued and for them to clarify (and then hope they don’t give an even lower score )

[Cacciatore 19,347]

80 was a good score from the LA Times guys let's not bother him or he might change it to 60 

[viagra 1,642]

Remember Metacritics staff have never taken down these troll reviews with 0 score for BTD and BTW from Tiny Mix Tapes. They had to read them to get a summary, yet they thought they were completely ok to be counted. I wouldnt be suprised if they had their own agenda. I mean they are receptive to take down reviews for some albums, yet for others they act deaf.

 

They should also broaden their list of reviewing magazines. Why not include the Atlantic etc... I feel like we are getting less and less reviews for albums from the chosen ones.

[bartenders 1,206]

~85 is still a very decent MC score and im happy for her 

[ArtDecoDelRey 15,284]

https://www.breezejmu.org/culture/norman-fucking-rockwell-is-lana-del-rey-s-best-album/article_5ef2f3a2-cce7-11e9-8164-33536b34f151.html

 

5 stars! Highly doubt that it counts for metacritic