Anonymcomenter

I also feel this like deep inside she´s genuine and talented but why we always end up getting the mids recently? FTB sessions are very interesting and its crazy some of them didnt make the cut... 

I want her to put Lessons, Afraid of the Dark and Charades on streaming platforms! 

Idgaf about this fuckers opinion, this album is a 10 in my mind! Maybe it could be a little shorter… no interludes and maybe 2-3 tracks less and it would be PERFECT! But as it is it’s great too, just like Stripped 
 
I must say tho… the deluxe tracks eat… HARD! Alice of the Upper Class, Lessons, Nothing, Afraid of the Dark, Charades… hope she releases em on digital form at some point 
 
for me the perfect Tracklist would be: 
 
1.        Only Living Girl in LA
2.        Alice of the Upper Class
3.        Ego 
4.        Dog Years
5.        I Believe in Magic 
6.        Panic Attack 
7.        Darwinism 
8.        Lonely is the Muse 
9.        Arsonist 
10.      Lessons
11.      I Never Loved You 
12.      Life of the Spider (Draft) 
13.      Hometown
14.      Charades
15.      The Great Impersonator
 
ps: I get u can have an opinion, and ur entitled to it… but I saw both Fantanos and Pitchforks reviews and to say those things about a person opening up about things so personal… feels… out of touch! They may think they’re edgy but instead they look like idiots to me. Even if u don’t like her as a person (I once didn’t like her either) or think she’s cringe, there’s some lines you shouldn’t cross… it’s almost sociological! Even Fantanos comment section was pointing this out, and that rare since everytime all u can find there are stupid one liners and people licking his pretentious ass 

They still mad about that tweet 

I mean… the run from I Never Loved You to Life of the Spider (Draft) is INSANE! 

Im soooooo addicted to Arsonist! Such a BOP 
 
specially after looking all the meaning in Genius, love her more for that 

We need the Kim demo to leak cuz u know… its probably the best version 

Kim confirmed she wrote Gorgeous in 2022 meaning my theory about the label powers keeping Kim locked away and sapping the talent out of her and giving it to bigger artists is looking truer everyday 

In Afraid of the Dark she sings like she's a scared sad child and I mean that in the best way possible. It actually scares me to feel that song.

They still mad about that tweet 

Im soooooo addicted to Arsonist! Such a BOP 
 
specially after looking all the meaning in Genius, love her more for that 

Idgaf about this fuckers opinion, this album is a 10 in my mind! Maybe it could be a little shorter… no interludes and maybe 2-3 tracks less and it would be PERFECT! But as it is it’s great too, just like Stripped 
 
I must say tho… the deluxe tracks eat… HARD! Alice of the Upper Class, Lessons, Nothing, Afraid of the Dark, Charades… hope she releases em on digital form at some point 
 
for me the perfect Tracklist would be: 
 
1.        Only Living Girl in LA
2.        Alice of the Upper Class
3.        Ego 
4.        Dog Years
5.        I Believe in Magic 
6.        Panic Attack 
7.        Darwinism 
8.        Lonely is the Muse 
9.        Arsonist 
10.      Lessons
11.      I Never Loved You 
12.      Life of the Spider (Draft) 
13.      Hometown
14.      Charades
15.      The Great Impersonator
 
ps: I get u can have an opinion, and ur entitled to it… but I saw both Fantanos and Pitchforks reviews and to say those things about a person opening up about things so personal… feels… out of touch! They may think they’re edgy but instead they look like idiots to me. Even if u don’t like her as a person (I once didn’t like her either) or think she’s cringe, there’s some lines you shouldn’t cross… it’s almost sociological! Even Fantanos comment section was pointing this out, and that rare since everytime all u can find there are stupid one liners and people licking his pretentious ass 

Idgaf about this fuckers opinion, this album is a 10 in my mind! Maybe it could be a little shorter… no interludes and maybe 2-3 tracks less and it would be PERFECT! But as it is it’s great too, just like Stripped 
 
I must say tho… the deluxe tracks eat… HARD! Alice of the Upper Class, Lessons, Nothing, Afraid of the Dark, Charades… hope she releases em on digital form at some point 
 
for me the perfect Tracklist would be: 
 
1.        Only Living Girl in LA
2.        Alice of the Upper Class
3.        Ego 
4.        Dog Years
5.        I Believe in Magic 
6.        Panic Attack 
7.        Darwinism 
8.        Lonely is the Muse 
9.        Arsonist 
10.      Lessons
11.      I Never Loved You 
12.      Life of the Spider (Draft) 
13.      Hometown
14.      Charades
15.      The Great Impersonator
 
ps: I get u can have an opinion, and ur entitled to it… but I saw both Fantanos and Pitchforks reviews and to say those things about a person opening up about things so personal… feels… out of touch! They may think they’re edgy but instead they look like idiots to me. Even if u don’t like her as a person (I once didn’t like her either) or think she’s cringe, there’s some lines you shouldn’t cross… it’s almost sociological! Even Fantanos comment section was pointing this out, and that rare since everytime all u can find there are stupid one liners and people licking his pretentious ass 

Idgaf about this fuckers opinion, this album is a 10 in my mind! Maybe it could be a little shorter… no interludes and maybe 2-3 tracks less and it would be PERFECT! But as it is it’s great too, just like Stripped 
 
I must say tho… the deluxe tracks eat… HARD! Alice of the Upper Class, Lessons, Nothing, Afraid of the Dark, Charades… hope she releases em on digital form at some point 
 
for me the perfect Tracklist would be: 
 
1.        Only Living Girl in LA
2.        Alice of the Upper Class
3.        Ego 
4.        Dog Years
5.        I Believe in Magic 
6.        Panic Attack 
7.        Darwinism 
8.        Lonely is the Muse 
9.        Arsonist 
10.      Lessons
11.      I Never Loved You 
12.      Life of the Spider (Draft) 
13.      Hometown
14.      Charades
15.      The Great Impersonator
 
ps: I get u can have an opinion, and ur entitled to it… but I saw both Fantanos and Pitchforks reviews and to say those things about a person opening up about things so personal… feels… out of touch! They may think they’re edgy but instead they look like idiots to me. Even if u don’t like her as a person (I once didn’t like her either) or think she’s cringe, there’s some lines you shouldn’t cross… it’s almost sociological! Even Fantanos comment section was pointing this out, and that rare since everytime all u can find there are stupid one liners and people licking his pretentious ass 

They are odious. I get not liking Halsey as a person, I am not a fan of her music aside from her rockier sound, but this record is in no way close a one. P4K and Fantano have always had this weird hate towards Miley Cyrus and Lana Del Rey too, which I am sure they only changed their minds on because it drove their website clicks and because Lana's influence is undeniable. I used to enjoy Pitchfork but they've become a cesspool that thrives on hit pieces that deviate from music criticism and hyper-focus on the artist's personal lives a little too much.
 
It's good that people are lashing out at them. Also, Fantano is an idiot who lets his biases influence his music critiques. I dunno why people enjoy his stuff. He seems like the type of person who interrupts you every other second with shit-tier mansplaining takes. His influence comes from a circlejerk of people who cannot come up with their own opinions re: music.
 
IDK, ganging up on somebody when they share something so profound to them and something that touches such serious subjects is really childish and unprofessional as fuck.

PREACH

The fantano and P4K reviews make me so unreasonably mad. This isn't the best album of the year, of course, but there are at least 6 tracks on here that are absolutely stellar. I was so shocked on so many moments of the album when she went so far and so personal, revealing her deepest secrets about death, sickness, family trauma. This album is so personal that it feels even uncomfortable to listen to, like you're reading someone else's diary. And yet, you have sick fucks like Fantano and pitchfork who go out saying she's trying to get clout, be some attention seeker???? So what you're saying is she suffered through cancer for our entertainment, so she could make some money??? I don't fucking get it. If I was Halsey, I would never release an album again, but I hope she ignores these rats and knows that she really made something important that resonated with a lot of people. Just needed to soapbox abt that 

the review was about everything except the music. it was pure yap trash. also anthony fantano gave this album a 1 and said "boohoo you have cancer? get over it". his "review" was equally as bad as pitchfork's if not worse and entirely mean spirited for no reason.
 
its so weird to me that anyone who says "this album is bad" just happens to have a negative bias against halsey and actually don't care about the music that much. but anyway stream the great impersonator 

They still mad about that tweet 

They still mad about that tweet 

I enjoy it, but I do agree with what someone on here said: it feels calculated. Pop music is having its moment right now where people are looking for something that catches you off guard at first; for example, Joyride by Kesha did so well in my opinion because of how crazy it sounded. Disease sounds like Lady Gaga tried to replicate some of her old sounds into one, which is a little TOO expected.

jesus p•tchf•ork are such haters how are u gonna give this record that rating??

Im soooooo addicted to Arsonist! Such a BOP 
 
specially after looking all the meaning in Genius, love her more for that 

I mean… the run from I Never Loved You to Life of the Spider (Draft) is INSANE! 

Im soooooo addicted to Arsonist! Such a BOP 
 
specially after looking all the meaning in Genius, love her more for that