Lust for Life Reviews/Metacritic Thread

[Miss Honeydew 615]

64-70. I think it will divide critics. Handful of positive but also a share of mixed.

 

[lustforlife 19,008]

i bet 72... 

[salp 1,696]

73. but she deserves 100. my girl doesn't care so neither do i 

[Dominikx4 25,029]

67, i think she'll get mixed reviews

[Off To The Races 2010 demo pls 19,335]

73 

[renaissance 8,131]

High 60s/low 70s

[TheBoss 13,374]

60-70

[lostindarkparadise 1,927]

54-65 

[Roll With me 5,640]

I predict moreless 67, maybe a little more since she has a legend like Stevie, got out of her zone to write different lyrics and explore new genres

[expandableclitoris 9,087]

54-65 

 

this tho

but i think tracks 11-16 will be great

[Brooklyn Baby 1,973]

77

[Afterparty 3,025]

70something

[thatsomason 1,201]

81

[t0mthem0m 47]

79

 

The album has a vast range of genres. From hip hop, to sad core pop like BTD, to indie and acoustics, we're getting everything. Her vocals are a little different as well. SHe's getting political.

[frankie 1,781]

around 65 or 70

[ilovetati 15,295]

79

 

The album has a vast range of genres. From hip hop, to sad core pop like BTD, to indie and acoustics, we're getting everything. Her vocals are a little different as well. SHe's getting political.

 

Critics don't usually like a mixture like this, though...unless you're Beyonce.

 

And as far as political goes, it has to be done right or you can end up like Katy Perry, so we shall see.

[Cloudbusting 5,383]

Around 68 - 76, even an 80 if the songs are even better than the snippets. Shakira got a 69 with her new album, which has many collabs and a big genre difference in the tracklist, which is more or less what Lana did. In all fairness, Shakira's album is a mess that even combined english and spanish and the songs just don't flow together. 

The critics may appreciate the fact that Lust For Life's tracklist has a very good order and everything fits. Also the only songs that may hurt her score are Lust For Life, Summer Bummer and Coachella. 

[naachoboy 7,977]

60 something

[longtimeman 8,144]

Critics will hate the political content - you have to be a middle aged male musician for your political viewpoint to be taken seriously by the media. Also, calling an original song 'Heroin' takes incredible guts, and I hope she doesn't pay too badly for it. I'm predicting a solid 76.

[SlowGinFizzzz 15,309]

I'd say around 65.