Pink Champagne

No you’re right

No you’re right

Midnights WISHES it had a hymn like that. Guilty As Sin is a reject from the Holy Bible

The hurricane
with my name
when it came

 

Like I lost my twin
Waving at the ship
 
I cannot stop singing that part 

this era needs to serve red dead redemption 

Why and how do we know this 

Fantano is ripping this album apart and it’s actually so embarrassing and making him really not respect him. I actually enjoy watching his reviews even when I disagree but wow the clip I saw of him reacting to it was just bad. He was just regurgitating the same tired Twitter takes that weren’t even about the music lol. Calling her creatively tired and a “perpetual victim” (which we could have an entire conversation on that critique and how irritating it is but whatever). The reviews on this album are so biased and I can’t wait in two years when people realize this is top 3 if not her best record lol. 

How Did It End? is really starting to break my heart 

I need to write a full review on this album because I have so many thoughts… I genuinely think this is her magnum opus 
2024 is the best year for music since 2019!

God every song just gets better and better each listen… the only songs I find myself genuinely disliking are Cassandra and The Manscript. But even those I just find them boring it’s not a song I HATE or anything.

I want him back so badly 

 

My signed vinyl came today!! And I got the most perfect heart!

And most of my other stuff came today too! Just waiting for my Black Dog variants. Everything came so much faster than 1989 and Speak Now!

Guys. I’m really eating my words. I’m so embarrassed. I’m starting to really like it… Thank you everybody in this thread for letting me post my initial thoughts without grilling me for them…  I’ll take the L this time. TayGod you’re always right I’m sorry for questioning you my queen.
 
I think my initial disappointment clouded my judgement and I wasn’t able to appreciate the album for what it is because I was so hung up on what I wanted it to be

Thought of callin' ya, but you won't pick up
'Nother fortnight lost in America
Move to Florida, buy the car you want
But it won't start up 'til you touch, touch, touch me
 
I MEANIDK what would make the song even better but this outrothanks daddy malone

I still need to dive into The Anthology but I’ve given TTPD a solid few listens and I honestly love it. 
 
Favorites (bold ones are extra special)
-Fortnight
-My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys
-Down Bad
-So Long, London
-Fresh Out The Slammer
-Florida!!!
-Guilty as Sin?
-Who’s Afraid of Little Old Me?
-The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived
-The Alchemy
 
Still haven’t clicked with these yet
-The Tortured Poets Department
-But Daddy I Love Him
-I Can Fix Him
-loml 
-I Can Do It With a Broken Heart
-Clara Bow

@Pink Champagne we have very similar taste! Agree with all your bolded songs, especially 

I still need to dive into The Anthology but I’ve given TTPD a solid few listens and I honestly love it. 
 
Favorites (bold ones are extra special)
-Fortnight
-My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys
-Down Bad
-So Long, London
-Fresh Out The Slammer
-Florida!!!
-Guilty as Sin?
-Who’s Afraid of Little Old Me?
-The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived
-The Alchemy
 
Still haven’t clicked with these yet
-The Tortured Poets Department
-But Daddy I Love Him
-I Can Fix Him
-loml 
-I Can Do It With a Broken Heart
-Clara Bow

I still need to dive into The Anthology but I’ve given TTPD a solid few listens and I honestly love it. 
 
Favorites (bold ones are extra special)
-Fortnight
-My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys
-Down Bad
-So Long, London
-Fresh Out The Slammer
-Florida!!!
-Guilty as Sin?
-Who’s Afraid of Little Old Me?
-The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived
-The Alchemy
 
Still haven’t clicked with these yet
-The Tortured Poets Department
-But Daddy I Love Him
-I Can Fix Him
-loml 
-I Can Do It With a Broken Heart
-Clara Bow

Yeah so far I’m wishing instead of a double album she would have done a folklore/evermore situation where she put out TTPD this month and TA in like September or October 
 
I can’t believe I’m saying this, but I’m really leaning towards Side A/Jack songs. Side B does have a lot of solid songs but idk it’s a BIT much I think

yeah might be an unpopular opinion but the album is kinda mid… plus why she still talking about kim?? girl get over it 

Yeah i’m no fan either but thats a crazy take

I feel like this is going to EAT

I feel like this is going to EAT