FkaTwinks

I'll start a spreadsheet 
 

I just:
Allie Hughes - Ladies and Gentlemen (Sessions) – Isn't This Funny Allie Hughes - The Hard Way – we know what was on it so I just place finals here i.e. We Are the Stars Allie Hughes - The Hard Way (Sessions) – Catch concept demo, I Will Love You More demo, etc. ALX - Unreleased – obvious, any mixes ALX performed live, came from scams/hacks for them, etc. Allie X - CollXtion I (Sessions) – anything recorded from ALX's disbandment until the end of 2014, including CFC tracks Allie X - CollXtion II (Sessions) – anything recorded from 2015-16 Allie X - Super Sunset (Sessions) – Dancing in the Dark, The Other Side Allie X - Cape God (Sessions) – Bad Man, SSYL demo

I just:
Allie Hughes - Ladies and Gentlemen (Sessions) – Isn't This Funny Allie Hughes - The Hard Way – we know what was on it so I just place finals here i.e. We Are the Stars Allie Hughes - The Hard Way (Sessions) – Catch concept demo, I Will Love You More demo, etc. ALX - Unreleased – obvious, any mixes ALX performed live, came from scams/hacks for them, etc. Allie X - CollXtion I (Sessions) – anything recorded from ALX's disbandment until the end of 2014, including CFC tracks Allie X - CollXtion II (Sessions) – anything recorded from 2015-16 Allie X - Super Sunset (Sessions) – Dancing in the Dark, The Other Side Allie X - Cape God (Sessions) – Bad Man, SSYL demo

I don't think Keenan single-handedly ruined K-12; The production's alright, it's the songs themselves. I think she struggled from having to write a full album around a very specific concept with a very limited number of things to reference and relevant experiences to write about, while also trying to shoehorn it into a pre-existing fictional universe; Besides the title convention, Cry Baby never really restricts itself in that way at any point.
 
Tl;dr if every song on MM3 has to force itself to lyrically/thematically be relevant to the main concept, it'll be just as bad as K-12.

Sculpture is just the version she leaked but in higher quality
 
I think Allie just used "Demo" as a synonym for "Previously Unheard/Unreleased" but might've left it off for Sculpture since it came from her accidental Soundcloud post / is a version we have; The reason she used a complete version of GLAM! is likely what she's been saying this whole campaign, which is that it's one of her favorite unreleased songs and she thinks it should have always been in CollXtion I; that's exactly why she gave it a real spot in the tracklist instead of making it a bonus track like everything else in this release, and why it's the only single.

Sculpture is just the version she leaked but in higher quality
 
I think Allie just used "Demo" as a synonym for "Previously Unheard/Unreleased" but might've left it off for Sculpture since it came from her accidental Soundcloud post / is a version we have; The reason she used a complete version of GLAM! is likely what she's been saying this whole campaign, which is that it's one of her favorite unreleased songs and she thinks it should have always been in CollXtion I; that's exactly why she gave it a real spot in the tracklist instead of making it a bonus track like everything else in this release, and why it's the only single.

Sculpture is just the version she leaked but in higher quality
 
I think Allie just used "Demo" as a synonym for "Previously Unheard/Unreleased" but might've left it off for Sculpture since it came from her accidental Soundcloud post / is a version we have; The reason she used a complete version of GLAM! is likely what she's been saying this whole campaign, which is that it's one of her favorite unreleased songs and she thinks it should have always been in CollXtion I; that's exactly why she gave it a real spot in the tracklist instead of making it a bonus track like everything else in this release, and why it's the only single.

I don't think Keenan single-handedly ruined K-12; The production's alright, it's the songs themselves. I think she struggled from having to write a full album around a very specific concept with a very limited number of things to reference and relevant experiences to write about, while also trying to shoehorn it into a pre-existing fictional universe; Besides the title convention, Cry Baby never really restricts itself in that way at any point.
 
Tl;dr if every song on MM3 has to force itself to lyrically/thematically be relevant to the main concept, it'll be just as bad as K-12.

I don't think Keenan single-handedly ruined K-12; The production's alright, it's the songs themselves. I think she struggled from having to write a full album around a very specific concept with a very limited number of things to reference and relevant experiences to write about, while also trying to shoehorn it into a pre-existing fictional universe; Besides the title convention, Cry Baby never really restricts itself in that way at any point.
 
Tl;dr if every song on MM3 has to force itself to lyrically/thematically be relevant to the main concept, it'll be just as bad as K-12.

I don't think Keenan single-handedly ruined K-12; The production's alright, it's the songs themselves. I think she struggled from having to write a full album around a very specific concept with a very limited number of things to reference and relevant experiences to write about, while also trying to shoehorn it into a pre-existing fictional universe; Besides the title convention, Cry Baby never really restricts itself in that way at any point.
 
Tl;dr if every song on MM3 has to force itself to lyrically/thematically be relevant to the main concept, it'll be just as bad as K-12.

Okay? What does that have to do with anything, she still confirmed it was on the album as a bonus track until she wrote more songs and it got knocked off 

Okay? What does that have to do with anything, she still confirmed it was on the album as a bonus track until she wrote more songs and it got knocked off 

She confirmed in this interview that it was supposed to be a bonus track on Cry Baby: https://theknockturnal.com/an-exclusive-interview-with-melanie-martinez/

She confirmed in this interview that it was supposed to be a bonus track on Cry Baby: https://theknockturnal.com/an-exclusive-interview-with-melanie-martinez/

Bombs On Monday and Haunted were replaced as well, according to this rumor from very early 2015 (long before either song was really confirmed to exist):

 
I would assume WDBCF? was also replaced by Teddy Bear or Half Hearted/Play Date, since she confirmed it was supposed to be a bonus track.
 

I think those are just Dollhouse outtakes; It can be said that the Dollhouse era generally didn't have a deliberate concept (aside from toy sounds being used in many of the songs' instrumentals), but Cry Baby was always focused on the childlike theme it ended up having; Half Hearted is debatably the only song I named to have absolutely no correlation to the theme whatsoever, which makes sense since it wasn't written for the album and then was only considered as a bonus track.

99c Store, Band Aid, Bombs on Monday, Half Hearted, Haunted, the solo version of I Scream, Jumprope, King of the Arcade, Unhappy Meal and Zzzz are Cry Baby rejects. Almost everything else is Dollhouse EP and prior.

I think those are just Dollhouse outtakes; It can be said that the Dollhouse era generally didn't have a deliberate concept (aside from toy sounds being used in many of the songs' instrumentals), but Cry Baby was always focused on the childlike theme it ended up having; Half Hearted is debatably the only song I named to have absolutely no correlation to the theme whatsoever, which makes sense since it wasn't written for the album and then was only considered as a bonus track.

99c Store, Band Aid, Bombs on Monday, Half Hearted, Haunted, the solo version of I Scream, Jumprope, King of the Arcade, Unhappy Meal and Zzzz are Cry Baby rejects. Almost everything else is Dollhouse EP and prior.

I think those are just Dollhouse outtakes; It can be said that the Dollhouse era generally didn't have a deliberate concept (aside from toy sounds being used in many of the songs' instrumentals), but Cry Baby was always focused on the childlike theme it ended up having; Half Hearted is debatably the only song I named to have absolutely no correlation to the theme whatsoever, which makes sense since it wasn't written for the album and then was only considered as a bonus track.

I mean I'd be sick of it too if I were her; She started writing/teasing it in 2016 

Glam final version (snippet)
 
Susie Save Your Love solo version (snippet)
 

I mean I'd be sick of it too if I were her; She started writing/teasing it in 2016 

I mean I'd be sick of it too if I were her; She started writing/teasing it in 2016