EXODUS 9,925 Posted February 22, 2021 Yeah, I don't know why most artist don't release mixtapes, compilations or EPs with songs that they don't want to be attached to their main discography (Albums). Sky did good releasing As If! and Ghost, even though I believe she could've released another EP in between As If! and Ghost and get more outtakes from those shelved albums to the fans. Now, in the other hand, NTMT Bsides was a HUGE missed opportunity, she wasted so much space with two remixes when she could've added Pretty Dull and I'm Not Alright. Fuck, why even call it "Part 1" when she left that shit incomplete just as some of the demos that have leaked lol. At this point, she could've released an EP or two at least or some mixtapes. She doesn't want the money, she just wants a critical acclaimed album, at this point she could have the cash and the fans happy if she releases mixtapes with songs that she doesn't consider worthy to be on a full album. Ugh, just stop blaming the label. 5 Quote Hikaru Utada • BANKS • Rina Sawayama • Aly & AJ • MARINA • Björk • Kate Bush • Marion Ravn • Carly Rae Jepsen • Hilary Duff • Charli XCX • The Cardigans • Mitski • Phoebe Bridgers • Allie X • Caroline Polachek • Meg & Dia • Dia Frampton • Olivia Lufkin • Poppy • Grimes • Melanie Martinez • Lana Del Rey • Bat for Lashes • Ayumi Hamasaki • Paramore • Hayley Williams • Evanescence/Amy Lee • ACO • LIGHTS • Alexz Johnson • Avril Lavigne • Florrie • Flyleaf/Lacey Sturm • Tove Lo • Sky Ferreira • HANA • Daine • Foxes • CHVRCHES • Lorde Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Monsef 669 Posted February 22, 2021 2 hours ago, EXODUS said: Yeah, I don't know why most artist don't release mixtapes, compilations or EPs with songs that they don't want to be attached to their main discography (Albums).. THAT part! they're so weirdly selective and anal but when it comes to a new single they don't mind littering their am/spotify pages with 284834 remixes. 3 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Glitter Boy 16,616 Posted February 22, 2021 3 hours ago, EXODUS said: Yeah, I don't know why most artist don't release mixtapes, compilations or EPs with songs that they don't want to be attached to their main discography (Albums). Sky did good releasing As If! and Ghost, even though I believe she could've released another EP in between As If! and Ghost and get more outtakes from those shelved albums to the fans. Now, in the other hand, NTMT Bsides was a HUGE missed opportunity, she wasted so much space with two remixes when she could've added Pretty Dull and I'm Not Alright. Fuck, why even call it "Part 1" when she left that shit incomplete just as some of the demos that have leaked lol. At this point, she could've released an EP or two at least or some mixtapes. She doesn't want the money, she just wants a critical acclaimed album, at this point she could have the cash and the fans happy if she releases mixtapes with songs that she doesn't consider worthy to be on a full album. Ugh, just stop blaming the label. I hate EPs as they're too short, but I HEAVILY agree with this. I mean, maybe she could've dropped a mixtape every 18 months since the release of NMTM and they would've been well received ('cause we know sis always delivers) and she would be receiving money from the streamings, instead of receiving nothing from the files sitting on her laptop / wherever they are. This type of missed chances make more unbearable the fact that we've had less than 10 (officially released) songs from her in 7 years. And also DAMN YES to the NMTM B-Sides situation. I was expecting three installments, each with 4 unreleased songs at least. It's such a shame we only had one part with only three new songs. Not that I regret having it, but it's too little compared to what it seemed to be. 4 Quote "I'm wild, I'm free, no man can handle me" Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
details 17,447 Posted February 22, 2021 plzzzz why did you brought up the ntmt b-sides now i remembered that we never got a part 2 and i'm even madder! i mean why would you call it "part 1" if you never intended to release a part 2? 6 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Glitter Boy 16,616 Posted February 22, 2021 15 minutes ago, Honeysuckle said: plzzzz why did you brought up the ntmt b-sides now i remembered that we never got a part 2 and i'm even madder! i mean why would you call it "part 1" if you never intended to release a part 2? EXACTLY! So many songs to fit in a part 2, 3... I still wonder why did she never continue those releases. 2 Quote "I'm wild, I'm free, no man can handle me" Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
EXODUS 9,925 Posted February 23, 2021 7 hours ago, Monsef said: THAT part! they're so weirdly selective and anal but when it comes to a new single they don't mind littering their am/spotify pages with 284834 remixes. And most of them terribly bad 7 hours ago, Honeysuckle said: plzzzz why did you brought up the ntmt b-sides now i remembered that we never got a part 2 and i'm even madder! i mean why would you call it "part 1" if you never intended to release a part 2? It's an insult 6 hours ago, Glitter Boy said: EXACTLY! So many songs to fit in a part 2, 3... I still wonder why did she never continue those releases. It's quite dumb, huh? I highly doubt it was the label decision to halt the releases, they want money after all and they fucking know she is a critics darling and she gets invited a lot to festivals and her shows sells well... Sky, you have no excuse but your ego. 2 Quote Hikaru Utada • BANKS • Rina Sawayama • Aly & AJ • MARINA • Björk • Kate Bush • Marion Ravn • Carly Rae Jepsen • Hilary Duff • Charli XCX • The Cardigans • Mitski • Phoebe Bridgers • Allie X • Caroline Polachek • Meg & Dia • Dia Frampton • Olivia Lufkin • Poppy • Grimes • Melanie Martinez • Lana Del Rey • Bat for Lashes • Ayumi Hamasaki • Paramore • Hayley Williams • Evanescence/Amy Lee • ACO • LIGHTS • Alexz Johnson • Avril Lavigne • Florrie • Flyleaf/Lacey Sturm • Tove Lo • Sky Ferreira • HANA • Daine • Foxes • CHVRCHES • Lorde Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Sitar 22,218 Posted February 23, 2021 As if Halsey and Nasty Cherry didn't deserve the shade 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
love deluxe 8,862 Posted February 23, 2021 1 hour ago, EXODUS said: And most of them terribly bad It's an insult It's quite dumb, huh? I highly doubt it was the label decision to halt the releases, they want money after all and they fucking know she is a critics darling and she gets invited a lot to festivals and her shows sells well... Sky, you have no excuse but your ego. okay but we have no true real idea of what goes on behind the scenes so to assume sky is a liar without a shred of evidence towards that statement (that I'm aware of, at least), is kind of weird and wrong, in my opinion. she definitely wants to release her album. i find it weird that someone would lie about something like this in order to delay their album, and to reduce it to her ego is making big assumptions about a human that you don't even know personally, soooo idk. 2 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Monsef 669 Posted February 23, 2021 1 hour ago, Sitar said: As if Halsey and Nasty Cherry didn't deserve the shade No it's true its true! Especially Nasty Cherry, their music is just awful. WDYLIM is a worse version of EIE (which... that song is already Losing You by solange the re-up but thats not here nor there) 2 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Nightmare 9,850 Posted February 23, 2021 2 hours ago, Sitar said: As if Halsey and Nasty Cherry didn't deserve the shade at least they write their songs and don’t claim they invented a whole music genre? plssss 4 Quote come to my house let's die together, friendships that would last forever Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
HEARTCORE 18,971 Posted February 23, 2021 gays have a weird obsession with female artists and telling them what they can and cannot do. all i'll say is that it's pretty common for songwriters to write stuff together and not immediately record it, sometimes they'll have just one of the writers record vox to see how it sounds/to help them with potentially pitching it to other artists. do i think that sky is a fraud? idk and idc, but the fact that there is another writer's demo ≠ she doesn't write her own stuff. 25 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Moon River 2,365 Posted February 23, 2021 It's also really funny to me that some of y'all think this is the exposé of the century when no one is checking for her anymore. 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
EXODUS 9,925 Posted February 23, 2021 Idk guys, I'm just waiting for her to finally address this situation. I highly doubt that for 8 years she has been sabotaged by her label 1 Quote Hikaru Utada • BANKS • Rina Sawayama • Aly & AJ • MARINA • Björk • Kate Bush • Marion Ravn • Carly Rae Jepsen • Hilary Duff • Charli XCX • The Cardigans • Mitski • Phoebe Bridgers • Allie X • Caroline Polachek • Meg & Dia • Dia Frampton • Olivia Lufkin • Poppy • Grimes • Melanie Martinez • Lana Del Rey • Bat for Lashes • Ayumi Hamasaki • Paramore • Hayley Williams • Evanescence/Amy Lee • ACO • LIGHTS • Alexz Johnson • Avril Lavigne • Florrie • Flyleaf/Lacey Sturm • Tove Lo • Sky Ferreira • HANA • Daine • Foxes • CHVRCHES • Lorde Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Glitter Boy 16,616 Posted February 23, 2021 1 hour ago, HEARTCORE said: gays have a weird obsession with female artists and telling them what they can and cannot do. all i'll say is that it's pretty common for songwriters to write stuff together and not immediately record it, sometimes they'll have just one of the writers record vox to see how it sounds/to help them with potentially pitching it to other artists. do i think that sky is a fraud? idk and idc, but the fact that there is another writer's demo ≠ she doesn't write her own stuff. 1 Quote "I'm wild, I'm free, no man can handle me" Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
alkolmoldah 2,076 Posted February 23, 2021 7 hours ago, Sitar said: As if Halsey and Nasty Cherry didn't deserve the shade What did Nasty Cherry do? 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
HEARTCORE 18,971 Posted February 23, 2021 51 minutes ago, alkolmoldah said: What did Nasty Cherry do? exist 5 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
paradiso 1,639 Posted February 23, 2021 can we please just go back to begging for don't forget and descending... 2 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
EXODUS 9,925 Posted February 23, 2021 10 hours ago, Sitar said: As if Halsey and Nasty Cherry didn't deserve the shade omg hahahaha, tbh I stan for Halsey's latest album, the other two are just ok to me 8 hours ago, Monsef said: No it's true its true! Especially Nasty Cherry, their music is just awful. WDYLIM is a worse version of EIE (which... that song is already Losing You by solange the re-up but thats not here nor there) Not a fan, but they are kinda ok 3 hours ago, alkolmoldah said: What did Nasty Cherry do? 2 hours ago, HEARTCORE said: exist Omg hahaha, now that's the shade lol (I love your posts sis) Nasty Cherry is just an experiment curated by Charli XCX, those 4 girls were FORCED to be a band, they are people that Charli know but they don't even get along... I mean, if you have seen the Netflix show you can tell that Chloe Chaidez (who is also the frontwoman of the indie rock band "Kitten") is very problematic and looked very upset of not being the center of the attention and the main singer. Charli "The Boss" XCX had to put her on her place and humble her in order to have the band work. At the end, Nasty Cherry only will last as long as the main singer is there, the other members are expendables (specually Chloe as she has her own band with a big fanbase), but I don't think they will ever release more than 1 album (if there's ever one). Their sound is very fabricated even though they are being sold to the public as a "real band". I see nothing organic on them. Do I like their music? yeah, a few tracks Am I a fan? Not quite Are they or Halsey better than Sky? fuck no, Sky music is better (don't care who wrote the tracks) Did Sky have the right to call them out? NO, that was so distateful and petty. 2 hours ago, paradiso said: can we please just go back to begging for don't forget and descending... You are allowed to beg, feel free to do it, nothing is stoping you 6 Quote Hikaru Utada • BANKS • Rina Sawayama • Aly & AJ • MARINA • Björk • Kate Bush • Marion Ravn • Carly Rae Jepsen • Hilary Duff • Charli XCX • The Cardigans • Mitski • Phoebe Bridgers • Allie X • Caroline Polachek • Meg & Dia • Dia Frampton • Olivia Lufkin • Poppy • Grimes • Melanie Martinez • Lana Del Rey • Bat for Lashes • Ayumi Hamasaki • Paramore • Hayley Williams • Evanescence/Amy Lee • ACO • LIGHTS • Alexz Johnson • Avril Lavigne • Florrie • Flyleaf/Lacey Sturm • Tove Lo • Sky Ferreira • HANA • Daine • Foxes • CHVRCHES • Lorde Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
eyelovelefteye 1,703 Posted February 23, 2021 7 hours ago, HEARTCORE said: gays have a weird obsession with female artists and telling them what they can and cannot do. all i'll say is that it's pretty common for songwriters to write stuff together and not immediately record it, sometimes they'll have just one of the writers record vox to see how it sounds/to help them with potentially pitching it to other artists. do i think that sky is a fraud? idk and idc, but the fact that there is another writer's demo ≠ she doesn't write her own stuff. Exactly! My guess is she had the lyrics written and this guy came up with the melody and instrumental as a reference track for her to record 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
drewby 9,249 Posted February 23, 2021 She (and the label ) never even positioned her as a songwriter, so frankly idc if she barely had any involvement in the writing process. This argument is circular and is tired from both sides 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites