Born to Die vs Ultraviolence

[Jack 2,919]

You guys are comparing the worst lyrics to the best

[FloridaDark 12]

Put my little red party dress on

Everybody knows that I'm the best, I'm crazy

Get a little bit of Bourbon in 'ya

Get a little bit suburban and go crazy

Because you're young, you're wild, you're free

You're dancing circles around me

You're fucking crazy

You're crazy for me

 

 

 

You don't see the irony in these lyrics? (just asking, i don't want to be rude)

I know it's all about personal taste, but in my opinion, Cruel World is one of her best songs. 

[Lirazel 700]

I've only listened to Ultraviolence in it's entirety like 3 times (because I'm kind off busy crying over how perfect the new Linkin Park record is).

I like it so far and I can't wait till it lies on my shelf.... but it has nothing on Born to Die. It will always be my fave, because it's what made me love Lana in the first place. And even though I think that Ultraviolence is an improvement over Paradise, I miss how different songs were on Born to Die. Ultraviolence sounds kind off samey... don't get me wrong, it's in a good way... but still. idk, I probably need to listen to it more.

 

[PrettyBaby 2,219]

 

But how can you say UV is too same-y when BTD has similar strings, hip hop samples, loon noises, that specific guitar sound etc. throughout almost every song? 

 

 

The writing/tempo was more varied on BTD.   And how can you say "how can you say UV is too same-y" without going on to give examples of how UV is not same-y? 

[dsvelca 837]

You don't see the irony in these lyrics? (just asking, i don't want to be rude)

I know it's all about personal taste, but in my opinion, Cruel World is one of her best songs.

I think I'd appreciate an explanation :-/

[Hundred Dollar Bill 21,804]

The writing/tempo was more varied on BTD. And how can you say "how can you say UV is too same-y" without going on to give examples of how UV is not same-y?

Her vocal range is more varied on UV, by a loooot. You go from BTD-esque range (songs like Guns and Roses & West Coast) to much higher, which she didn't do very much in BTD. Songs like Shades of Cool, Pretty When You Cry, FMWUTTT & some other moments in a few other songs.

 

I feel like everyone is confusing the atmosphere the album creates with it being "too same-y." Just because it's a cohesive work doesn't mean all the songs are really similar. There's a huge amount of guitar used throughout the album but it's used in different ways, making different sounds. PWYC doesn't sound like SoC but they both rely on lots of guitar. Same for Florida Kilos. I mean, a few songs seem like siblings to me, yeah, but not nearly as same-y as songs were on BTD.

 

Nothing else on UV sounds like The Other Woman, FK, PWYC, ITH, Flipside, UV, FMWUTTT, Old Money. Etc. Yeah the tempo overall is less varied, with UV being a slower, brooding album, but that doesn't mean it's too same-y! BTD just uses a lot of the same sound effects in the same way in lots of the songs throughout, and usually unsuccessfully.

[naachoboy 7,993]

Her vocal range is more varied on UV, by a loooot. You go from BTD-esque range (songs like Guns and Roses & West Coast) to much higher, which she didn't do very much in BTD. Songs like Shades of Cool, Pretty When You Cry, FMWUTTT & some other moments in a few other songs.

 

I feel like everyone is confusing the atmosphere the album creates with it being "too same-y." Just because it's a cohesive work doesn't mean all the songs are really similar. There's a huge amount of guitar used throughout the album but it's used in different ways, making different sounds. PWYC doesn't sound like SoC but they both rely on lots of guitar. Same for Florida Kilos. I mean, a few songs seem like siblings to me, yeah, but not nearly as same-y as songs were on BTD.

 

Nothing else on UV sounds like The Other Woman, FK, PWYC, ITH, Flipside, UV, FMWUTTT, Old Money. Etc. Yeah the tempo overall is less varied, with UV being a slower, brooding album, but that doesn't mean it's too same-y! BTD just uses a lot of the same sound effects in the same way in lots of the songs throughout, and usually unsuccessfully.

[Hellish 488]

I dont even know where to start

In terms of emotion and rawness....UV takes the cake. End of story. I think you're sonically confused if you think that BTD has more emotional variety than UV. 

 

Yes, BTD has more of the main-stream beats at times, and one of the main appeals of that album is that it had that fresh sound with such alternative vocals and lyrics. UV on the other hand is so perfectly dark. It is dark everywhere from the instrumentals to the lyrics.

 

Comparing any two sounds from the different records is ridiculous. Yes, they are BOTH good. But please do not waste your time comparing the likes of Diet Mtn Dew with Sad Girl. It's too different worlds. 

 

One thing that does bother me is that people are basing their opinions of UV on how BTD sounds. Think about it like this, if you continuously have the same sound on every record--people will get bored with you. UV is such a departure that any comparisons are just unjust. 

 

BTD= still a label-influenced album (let's be real)

UV= Lana getting her way and having the most stripped-back sound the label will allow.

[Hundred Dollar Bill 21,804]

Comparing any two sounds from the different records is ridiculous. Yes, they are BOTH good. But please do not waste your time comparing the likes of Diet Mtn Dew with Sad Girl. It's too different worlds.

But that's the point of this thread, to compare the albums. Yeah, they're very different, but they can still be compared in terms of aesthetics and such.

 

Besides, it's fun to discuss this stuff with everyone! I like proving people wrong.

[DanCastro 962]

Love them both, but Born To Die is the album of my life...

 

[Creyk 11,699]

 

 

 

The sun also rises on those who fail to call

My life, it comprises of losses and wins and fails and falls

I can do it if you really, really like that

I know what you really want, b-baby

I can do it if you think you like that

You should run, boy, run

 

Vs

 

You're no good for me,

baby, you’re no good for me.

You’re no good for me,

but baby, I want you, I want you.

 

Diet Mountain Dew, baby, New York City.

Can we hit it now, low-down and gritty?

Do you think we’ll be in love forever?

Do you think we’ll be in love?

 

Baby, put on heart-shaped sunglasses

'cause we’re gonna take a ride.

I’m not gonna listen to what the past says,

I been waiting up all night.

 

______________________________________

 

 

Blue hydrangea, cold cash, divine,

Cashmere, cologne and white sunshine.

Red racing cars, sunset in vine,

The kids were young and pretty.

 

Where have you been? Where did you go?

Those summer nights seem long ago,

And so is the girl you used to call,

The Queen of New York City.

 

Vs

 

Kiss me in the d-a-r-k dark tonight

(D-a-r-k, do it my way)

Kiss me in the p-a-r-k park tonight

(P-a-r-k, let them all say)

 

Hey Lolita, hey! Hey Lolita, hey!

I know what the boys want, I'm not gonna play

Hey Lolita, hey! Hey Lolita, hey!

 

______________________________________

 

I paint my nails black,

I dye my hair a darker shade of brown

Cause you like your women Spanish, dark, strong and proud

I paint the sky black

You said if you could have your way

You'd make a night time of today

So it'd suit the mood of your song

 

Oh, what can I do?

Nothing, my sparrow blue

Oh, what can I do?

Life is beautiful but you don't have a clue

Sun and ocean blue

Their magnificence, it don't make sense to you

 

Vs

 

All my friends tell me I should move on

I'm lying in the ocean, singing your song

Ahhh, that's how you sang it

Loving you forever, can't be wrong

Even though you're not here, won't move on

Ahhh, that's how we played it

 

Every time I close my eyes

It's like a dark paradise

 

_____________________________________

 

 

 

 

 

Did you really just contrast the flawless DMD lyrics with the mediocre ones?

Gurl that's a missed shot

 

/DP is perfect bye

[GodBlessMe 2,141]

Did you really just contrast the flawless DMD lyrics with the mediocre ones?

Gurl that's a missed shot

 

/DP is perfect bye

DMD lyrics are terrible and DP is cringeworthy...

[Creyk 11,699]

DMD lyrics are terrible and DP is cringeworthy...

 

You're so wrong sis

But well, It's good that at least one of us is right

 

 

Of course music is subjective dah

 

[GodBlessMe 2,141]

You're so wrong sis

But well, It's good that at least one of us is right

 

 

Of course music is subjective dah

 

Music is subjective!

Except for the fact that DMD is lyrically bad and DP is bad both sonically and lyrically....

[rubytuesday 222]

Born To Die. It's so special to me. I started listening to it having just started outpatient treatment for some issues and it was the first thing in a long time I loved because it made me feel free and young, rather than sad. I loved it on the very first listen, a couple of days before it was officially released and some of the demos were on YouTube. Ultraviolence is maybe the more mature record, possibly the "better" record but BTD will always be my favourite. Iconic for me.

[Hundred Dollar Bill 21,804]

Music is subjective!

Except for the fact that DMD is lyrically bad and DP is bad both sonically and lyrically....

   

 

GodBlessYou

[GodBlessMe 2,141]

   

 

GodBlessYou

God bless you too!!!

[IamWhatYouDesire 55]

I love both and I picked both. I find it hard to get back to BTD now when Ultraviolence is on such a different level,but I really miss it's style. A lot 

[primadonna_teen 20]

I miss the beats and strings of BTD. However, there is something about Ultraviolence that is able to transport you to a different era all together that BTD never was able to do. It was like a channeling of an energy of some sort, I'm not sure. But as of right now, ultraviolence beats BTD.

[Ari 88]

Born To Die will always have a very special place in my heart. I could incessantly listen to every single song on that album. At this point, I like BTD better than UV.

 

Ultraviolence is more mature and takes on a different theme, though. It's definitely more solemn, stripped down, cinematic, and rock-influenced. UV is still growing on me, but I think it's a masterful album. The thing is - I don't think that all the songs on this album could be a single, unlike BTD.