Random Lana Discussion Thread

[Dark Angel 202,387]

11 minutes ago, LanaTheRay said:

Why is everyone ultimately placing the blame on Jack, it’s Lorde’s song at the end of the day. None of Jack’s other songs in the past sound like songs he’s done with other artists. No song on Reputation that he did with Taylor sound like any NFR songs or any of his work with St. Vincent. Stoned sounds like Wild at heart cause it shares the exact same chord progression, maybe it’s Lorde’s that’s the uninspired one, not Jack

 

yes, i agree, obviously if lorde knew that her song was basically recycling lana's song it would also be her fault, i just didn't wanna assume because jack's the one who produced it, and you know how stans can be...  i'm not saying lorde is 100% innocent, i guess we don't really know for sure, either way, i think it's suspicious

[IanadeIrey 62,021]

I know it’s off topic but re: the Lorde talk-

 

She did say that she made this album to “amuse [her] peers” and that she wanted certain musicians to listen to it, text her, and say “I see what you did there”. So, I wonder if the similarities between her new stuff and Lana’s signature sound/lyricism is deliberate...

[Dark Angel 202,387]

4 minutes ago, IanadeIrey said:

I know it’s off topic but re: the Lorde talk-

 

She did say that she made this album to “amuse [her] peers” and that she wanted certain musicians to listen to it, text her, and say “I see what you did there”. So, I wonder if the similarities between her new stuff and Lana’s signature sound/lyricism is deliberate...

 

i feel like that's a bad idea, considering lorde & lana's history  unless i'm out of the loop and they're friends or something  also just the idea of "borrowing" or being heavily inspired by somebody else's work and making it some sort of easter egg is strange, in my opinion

[IanadeIrey 62,021]

5 minutes ago, Surf Noir said:

 

i feel like that's a bad idea, considering lorde & lana's history,  unless i'm out of the loop and they're friends or something  also just the idea of "borrowing" or being heavily inspired by somebody else's work and making it some sort of easter egg...

I agree, and I don’t think Lana is necessarily a fan of people making similar music to her *especially* if they previously voiced their distaste for her music and didn’t bother to rectify such comments   

 

Although I’m not an avid listener or a fan, I think Lorde is a great musician, but I also think she should make music that sounds like...well, Lorde! I feel like after NFR, a lot of people wanted to create their own versions of that record and maybe I’m biased because it’s Lana, but nothing beats the original. 

[COCC 29,554]

11 minutes ago, Surf Noir said:

unless i'm out of the loop and they're friends or something

QFTC says hi  

[Dark Angel 202,387]

10 minutes ago, COCC said:

QFTC says hi  

 

qftc 2.0 is coming i fear  

 

now that taylor swift, st. vincent, clairo, the chicks, and lorde have produced hit albums with jack antonoff, can i please go back to singing about coffee pots, smoking cigarettes, loving lots like polka dots, and being wild at heart, without being copied or saying that i'm glamourizing jack antonoff?

[Make me your Dream Life 87,884]

like what if lorde was actually flirting with lana thru her music or something. that's a new perspective. she's like, no lana, I'M the prettier jesus. or, ey lets go get stoned getting pedi's girl. maybe it was jacks plan all along 

[COCC 29,554]

22 minutes ago, Diamantes WILD said:

like what if lorde was actually flirting with lana thru her music or something. that's a new perspective. she's like, no lana, I'M the prettier jesus. or, ey lets go get stoned getting pedi's girl. maybe it was jacks plan all along 

[rhubysyrup 4,501]

58 minutes ago, LanaTheRay said:

None of Jack’s other songs in the past sound like songs he’s done with other artists.

haha

https://www.tiktok.com/@drewsdiary/video/6950144302878035206?_d=secCgYIASAHKAESMgowpSpscJlyCSZpPL8iLQd26A36pLG6W%2BHeKgfxxXdvDrRReYRi4rWH0%2FWDIDMrpAWQGgA%3D&language=en&preview_pb=0&sec_user_id=MS4wLjABAAAAcJWQZYx8QVrypFNE9B9k56atf4-rTaldyS2uMOUB0FZj8jCUGfBXd2duVx8FtZC6&share_item_id=6950144302878035206&share_link_id=605436D3-2416-4238-A2E9-6FE59119B4E4&source=h5_m&timestamp=1618256027&tt_from=copy&u_code=dfg6hihc6i29ag&user_id=6896717675743413253&utm_campaign=client_share&utm_medium=ios&utm_source=copy&_r=1

[Make me your Dream Life 87,884]

3 minutes ago, COCC said:

[Macintosh Manhattan 6,511]

1 hour ago, rhubysyrup said:

haha

https://www.tiktok.com/@drewsdiary/video/6950144302878035206?_d=secCgYIASAHKAESMgowpSpscJlyCSZpPL8iLQd26A36pLG6W%2BHeKgfxxXdvDrRReYRi4rWH0%2FWDIDMrpAWQGgA%3D&language=en&preview_pb=0&sec_user_id=MS4wLjABAAAAcJWQZYx8QVrypFNE9B9k56atf4-rTaldyS2uMOUB0FZj8jCUGfBXd2duVx8FtZC6&share_item_id=6950144302878035206&share_link_id=605436D3-2416-4238-A2E9-6FE59119B4E4&source=h5_m&timestamp=1618256027&tt_from=copy&u_code=dfg6hihc6i29ag&user_id=6896717675743413253&utm_campaign=client_share&utm_medium=ios&utm_source=copy&_r=1

 

ROTFL , truly the most uninspired producer of recent times

 

He's a great guy  that's clear to see BC his peers including Lana etc wouldn't work with him otherwise but...yeah this ain't it chief 

 

I've seen more and more people starting to see through the veneer of his work and most of it is fair criticism. Links in spoiler.

 

Spoiler

 

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.vice.com/amp/en/article/9kxpn3/jack-antonoff-makes-a-lot-of-music-and-none-of-it-is-good

 

 

 

 

[Evergreen 8,389]

Imagine original versions of NFR!/COTCC tracks...

So glad Lana left him (for now).

[Honeyyoung 17,096]

36 minutes ago, Writer In The Dark said:

Imagine original versions of NFR!/COTCC tracks...

So glad Lana left him (for now).

wait but this is so perfect with the violins and everything??? why can't jack do something like this for lana

[CinnamonGay 10,527]

1 hour ago, Writer In The Dark said:

Imagine original versions of NFR!/COTCC tracks...

So glad Lana left him (for now).

 

Are u saying it's great?

[Dark Angel 202,387]

6 minutes ago, CinnamonGay said:

 

Are u saying it's great?

 

i think they mean "imagine nfr/cotcc tracks before jack produced them" meaning the original versions before jack's final versions

[Pink Flamingo 17,145]

2 hours ago, Writer In The Dark said:

Imagine original versions of NFR!/COTCC tracks...

So glad Lana left him (for now).

OK but this sounds Lana asffffff

[lustforlife 19,008]

The fact that nfr is so good that is Jack is trying to do it again with 3 artists, including lana 

[COCC 29,554]

3 hours ago, lustforlife said:

The fact that nfr is so good that is Jack is trying to do it again with 3 artists, including lana 

I guess you could call NFR… textbook 

[lanasbottom 23,694]

11 hours ago, Writer In The Dark said:

Imagine original versions of NFR!/COTCC tracks...

So glad Lana left him (for now).

holy fuck these violins are faker than me 

[lemonadetan 5,088]

.