Most melancholic songs?

[bluechemtrails 26,493]

Hello,

what do you think are her most melancholic and depressing songs?

 

I start with "Wait For Life"

[YourGirl666 13,231]

Hope, Fine China, God Knows I Tried, The Blackest Day, Wait for Life, Beautiful People demo, Nectar of the Gods, Cruel World, Pretty When I Cry, Terrence Loves You, Boom Like That

[daphnedinkley 13,372]

for me, melancholy is separated from sadness by a kind of... wistfulness? a sort of weird sad magic feeling. lana has many straight up depressing songs - Is This Happiness, Hope, Beautiful People demo, etc - but she is an absolute master when it comes to melancholy!

 

to me her most melancholic songs are: Oh Say Can You See, Yayo (both AKA and Paradise versions!), Pawn Shop Blues, Bel Air (!!!), and probably a few others i can't think of rn!!

 

controversial opinion: i actually think Tulsa Jesus Freak is super melancholic 

[rightofjupiter 16,489]

Terrence Loves You is one of the saddest (and best imo ) songs. I’d also add is this happiness. The other woman, the original demos for lust for life & BPBP, & hope is a dangerous thing. 

[ShadesOfFool 20,111]

God Knows I Tried, Ultraviolence, Old Money, most of honeymoon

[Mer 61,199]

Mariners Apartment Complex is melancholic to me, because while she’s finally able to say how strong she is, how secure she is; she realizes that other’s still don’t see her like that, so there’s this almost kind of pleading of “no I AM strong I’m not that person anymore” that I really like. 

[Flowerbomb 65,592]

Starry Eyed, Flipside, Swan Song, You're Gonna Love Me (just to name a few)

[Alison by Slowdive 26,130]

Try Tonight, Elvis, I Talk To Jesus, Fordham Road (idk if others feel the same way - I might be projecting lol), Nectar Of The Gods, The greatest, Lust For Life demo

 

8 hours ago, daphnedinkley said:

controversial opinion: i actually think Tulsa Jesus Freak is super melancholic 

 

I think I agree 

[bluechemtrails 26,493]

12 hours ago, YourGirl666 said:

Beautiful People demo

How the removal of the line "She wants to die" changed the whole song

[Thunder Revenant 20,936]

Well, on the one hand there is Pretty When You Cry, which is probably her darkest, most raw-est, desperate and truly saddest track.

But both The greatest and 13 Beaches hit a bit harder for me. Even though the lyrics maynot go as deep as songs like Heroin, The Blackest Day etc. the delivery, the mood and the production (especially in case of 13 Beaches) just SOAKS of melancholia, regret and defeat. In TG this vibe kind of clashes with those dramatics guitars, while the nautic sounds of 13B completely embrace it while still staying subtle

[Rachel97 1,525]

For me, it's Terrence Loves You. Those strings and the saxophone always gets me

 

Honorable mention to Pawn Shop Blues. So simple but so effective 

[Fingertips 72,034]

Honeymoon, Pawn Shop Blues, Terrence Loves You, White Dress, Arcadia, I Talk To Jesus, Cherry Blossom, Living Legend, Fine China, Swan Song, Pretty When You Cry, Change

[Ultra Violet 18,850]

Fine China, Ultraviolence (especially the demo and the first live performance), The Blackest Day, Dark Paradise (stereotypically, but it still is melancholic), Terrence Loves You, HIADTFAWLMTH (even though it attempts to life it at the end), Old Money (that one personally feels most melancholy to me)

[pawnshop 998]

Old Money and Pawn Shop Blues 

[bluechemtrails 26,493]

Not to forget Black Beauty, it looks like most melancholic songs are found on UV and Honeymoon.

[Manson 1,142]

Old Money, Say Yes to Heaven, Damn You, Pawn Shop Blues.

[sweetie 6,627]

I've always found White Mustang pretty melancholic. It's the saddest song on LFL, imo, next to Tomorrow Never Came and 13 Beaches. 

[Alison by Slowdive 26,130]

Next To Me (the ache of her loneliness is palpable)

[Super Movie 51,550]

Hope and Wait For Life. I have to be in a really specific mood to listen to those songs, they hurt in a completely different way than the rest of her discography does. I feel like Yosemite is melancholic as well, but in more of a nostalgic way rather than it being genuinely sad 

[cranekiss 9,728]

my song 57