Blue Banisters - Post-Release Discussion Thread + Poll

[Honeyyoung 17,090]

huge unpopular opinion in advance... but BBS and dealer really aren't the serve everyone thinks they are. i'm glad lana released them because it just feels like something she needed to get off her system but the actual songs (BBS in particular) are very messy and weird, i think i liked them at first because it was a change from the piano formula but i actually prefer well crafted piano songs then badly constructed songs from another genre

[Summerain 1,269]

My top 5:

If You Lie Down With Me

Wildflower Wildfire

Black Bathing Suit

Sweet Carolina

Blue Banisters

[LetTheLightln 1,486]

not the BB slander again  it might be the visuals (or rather the lack of them) that killed COCC for me or the time it came out that wasn't too good for me but BB is miles better for me and it's impossible to merge these albums together for me

 

my top 5, based mostly on how often i listen to these songs:

1. if you lie down with me

2. text book

3. thunder

4. arcadia

5. violets for roses

WW and dealer next!

 

[blackestday x tough 5,330]

My top 5

 

Wfwf

Arcadia

Thunder

Iyldwm

Bbs

[ShadesOfViolence 6,627]

my top 5

1. Wildflower Wildfire

2. If you lie down

3. Thunder

4. Nectar of the gods

5. Living Legend

[Vertimus 9,547]

And mine, as a LOVER of BB except, ironically, for the title track: 

 

1) IYLDWM

2) VFR

3) Arcadia

4) WFWF

5) BBS 

 

I have to exclude the leaked tracks, which I love, but which I have been listening to for years and years. I do like the original version of 'Thunder' much better. 

[Vertimus 9,547]

3 minutes ago, Vertimus said:

And mine, as a LOVER of BB except, ironically, for the title track, which is ruined for me by the choruses about Nikki Lane, etc.:

 

1) IYLDWM

2) VFR

3) Arcadia

4) WFWF

5) BBS 

 

I have to exclude the leaked tracks, which I love, but which I have been listening to for years and years. I do like the original version of 'Thunder' much better. 

 

[bluechemtrails 26,499]

Here's my extended version of BB with songs she might refer to in each song:

• Text Book
  • Ol'Man River - Howard Keel
• Blue Banisters
  • Ladies of the Canyon - Joni Mitchell
  • Diamonds And Rust - Joan Baez
• Arcadia
  • You're Lost Little Girl - The Doors
• Interlude - The Trio
  • Il triello - Ennio Morricone
• Black Bathing Suit
• If You Lie Down With Me
  • Three Times A Lady - Commodores
• Beautiful
• Violets for Roses
  • Violets for Your Furs - Billie Holiday
• Dealer
• Thunder
  • Mr. Brightside - The Killers
  • Catch the Wind - Donovan
• Wildflower Wildfire
  • Comfortably Numb - Pink Floyd
  • Lithium - Nirvana
• Nectar Of The Gods
  • Honey Of The Vine - Matt Monro
• Living Legend
• Cherry Blossom
• Sweet Carolina

[lanasbottom 23,694]

1 hour ago, Veinsineon said:

Text Book, Wildflower Wildfire, Beautiful, and Violets For Roses are some of Lana’s most forgettable and bland songs ever. Text book is cute at best and the rest are just….. 

the awful vocals and clunky lyrics on arcadia, the pointless and jarring interlude made by her closeted ex, the grocery list ass lyrics on bb, the unnecessary youtube rips… oh yeah truly her worst mixta- i mean album ever 

[Thunder Revenant 20,936]

Can't stand all the BB slander, especially cause I feel like most of the critique isn't even really about the album itself but people being frustrated they did not get what they wanted.

 

The album still sits in my top 3 Lana albums 

[DeadSeaOfMercury 22,864]

9 minutes ago, lanasbottom said:

the awful vocals and clunky lyrics on arcadia, the pointless and jarring interlude made by her closeted ex, the grocery list ass lyrics on bb, the unnecessary youtube rips… oh yeah truly her worst mixta- i mean album ever 

Toyota & Land Rover ARE NOT Clunky.

I really think the Interlude is cool, The Ex not so much.

But WHO ELSE Can rip their own songs off YouTube for an Official release? that’s literally Iconic!

 

EDIT:

And the released Thunder destroys the Demo.

[Venice Jesus Whore 4,465]

49 minutes ago, Honeyyoung said:

huge unpopular opinion in advance... but BBS and dealer really aren't the serve everyone thinks they are. i'm glad lana released them because it just feels like something she needed to get off her system but the actual songs (BBS in particular) are very messy and weird, i think i liked them at first because it was a change from the piano formula but i actually prefer well crafted piano songs then badly constructed songs from another genre

 

BBS reminds me of 13 Beaches in that they both feel like songs that both stick out (almost feel out of place??) on their albums and sound like what I think a really advanced AI would spit out if you asked it to make a Lana Del Rey song. Like I don’t want to say they sound like a parody of Lana Del Rey because that’s extremely overcritical and more harsh than I mean it to sound, but they kinda sound like imitations of Lana songs? Or like Lana trying to imitate the sound of BTD/Paradise but make it sound slightly newer? Even though BBS isn’t the same style as BTD…

 

Am I making any sense? 

[blackestday x tough 5,330]

I understand the bb slander but wfwf and violets for Roses describing as bland is a Crime

[DeadSeaOfMercury 22,864]

Just now, blackestday89 said:

I understand the bb slander but wfwf and violets for Roses describing as bland is a Crime

Wfwf is one of the greatest songs she’s ever done!

[shadesofloveduthenandnow 20,610]

Her

 

anyway since we’re doing Top 5s, in no particular order:

Black Bathing Suit

Dealer

Wildflower Wildfire

If You Lie Down With Me

Thunder/Text Book, depending on the day

[blackestday x tough 5,330]

7 minutes ago, DeadSeaOfMercury said:

Wfwf is one of the greatest songs she’s ever done!

Top Taste!!!!

[Thunder Revenant 20,936]

22 minutes ago, lanasbottom said:

 the grocery list ass lyrics on bb

You mean CoCC?

[lanasbottom 23,694]

14 minutes ago, DeadSeaOfMercury said:

 

EDIT:

And the released Thunder destroys the Demo.

 

that brings us down to 1 great song out of 14 

[Deadly Nightshade 12,802]

Still traumatized by the choice of the PicsArt covers though 

[LifeOnMars 7,864]

My biggest problem with this album is that songs were literally ripped of YouTube. It makes me think that this album was rushed. This album would have been fine if it had been released as a mixtape or shortened to an EP.